Videocard for HTPC and/or video editing

Canuck1

Distinguished
Apr 1, 2007
452
0
18,790
I was wondering what a good budget card is for using with a HTPC and for doing video editing/encoding. For video converting, I assume the 8600 Nvidia series is good but would a 7xxx series card be almost as good if you have a good CPU? I'm building a computer and will probably get one of the Intel Core 2 Duo processors when they go on sale.

I might want an LCD TV but currently, I was using an LCD monitor and need the video card's DVI input. I was wondering what the min. requirements are and if you use a LCD TV, which video card is good (i.e. minimum requirements). I think you need at least a 6600 (7600 is better) for high definition. I am also wondering if it matters if you use a video card with dual DVI inputs or a video card with one DVI and one HDMI input. There are only a few video cards on the market with the DVI AND HDMI input and most are expensive. But, they would allow the direct HDMI hookup. However, I believe that a DVI to HDMI convertor cable adapter can deliver the same video signal. You just need to get audio separately (RCA etc.).

Could someone who knows this stuff explain and recommend?

Thanks.
 
Well if you're interested in video playback, then stick with a GF8600/8400 or HD2600/2400 and forget the previous generation. Both of those low-mid range series have better decoding performance and dedicated hardware than the older generation, and will payback protected content like a BR or HD-DVD disk much better (although downloaded content doesn't seem to experience as much of a difference). You can achieve similar results with an older card and a fast CPU, but one some of the higher bit-rate content the playback may be prone to hiccups, especially if other processes start working.

As for the connections, you want to ensure that any GF8 series you get has HDCP support (not all do) yet all the HD2K series have HDCP support.

DVI->HDMI works, but the main question is what input the TV has. You can get the cards with built in HDMI or the TVs with built in HDCP DVI support. Now the HD2K series allows you to do DVI->HDMI with their adapter (look for cards that ship with it in the bundle) and it provides audio over DVI to allow the HDMI to output audio without a separate cable. So that's something to consider.

Overall if you're not gaming, then I'd recommend you get an HD2400 or GF8400 card (with HDCP), both of which will do the video playback role best, and both of which will be fine for most editing tasks with just slight differences between the two.
 

prodystopian

Distinguished
Jul 7, 2006
259
0
18,780
If you are looking at the core 2 duos you may want to look at the AMD 6000+. It is about even par with the E6600 and is going for about $170. Also, if you don't game at all, go for the 2400. If you game a bit go with the 2600.
 

utaka95

Distinguished
Jan 12, 2006
375
0
18,780
I second Crashman's recommendation - Ati has more available wide screen resolutions, and is typically more tv compatible.
 

bfellow

Distinguished
Dec 22, 2006
779
0
18,980


For an HTPC I wouldn't go for the 6000+. I would go low end AMD chips for less power usage.
 


Yeah I forgot about that. You can of course make it work (had to do just that a few weeks back on my friend's new HP laptop), but it's a hassle and a half sometimes.
 

Canuck1

Distinguished
Apr 1, 2007
452
0
18,790

But, if the Core 2 Duos ever go on sale (post July 22), the E6750 is supposed to be under $200. I think it runs cooler (at least, at load or operation) than the AMD 6000+. Like one poster said, a slower AMD processor, such as the Brisbane 4800+, will run cooler but cannot approach the speeds and performance of the higher-end Core 2 Duos.

I was looking at a E6750 for the speed/performance equation. If it ever goes on sale, that is.
 

prodystopian

Distinguished
Jul 7, 2006
259
0
18,780
Intel has just released the refresh on the Core 2 Duo chips meaning that they have matched prices after the AMD drop. WIth that in mind I would definitely recommend going with one of these chips. I believe the e6550 is close to the e6600 and is going for about $163. Good luck.
 

San Pedro

Distinguished
Jul 16, 2007
1,286
12
19,295
ATI HD 2400 for what you're looking for. Cheap, passively cooled and it will do exactly what you're looking for, just don't expect to be playing any games on in high def.
 

utaka95

Distinguished
Jan 12, 2006
375
0
18,780
Anand's tested the 2400 and 2600 in comparison to the 8500 & 8600 and they said basically to avoid the 2400 and 8500 - overall performance was poor.