Archived from groups: alt.comp.periphs.mainboard.asus (
More info?)
A small follow-up to my previous post. It should be considered that
the usage of each HD has an impact on life expectancy. If the case
has poor ventilation/cooling, you might expect the HD to fail sooner,
particularly the 7200 rpm (or faster) HDs which tend to run quite
warm.
Presently, I have 2 HDs in this system, a WD and an IBM, both 40 gig.
The IBM is running 6-10 degrees C hotter due to the case design and
the internal placement of the HDs. I expect the IBM may not last as
long under these conditions. Presently, the WD drive is at 36C and
the IBM at 42C. I note the IBM drive is used only for early morning
HD backup right now, so it spins-down most of the time, yet its temp
remains much higher than the WD drive due to it's position within the
case (the IBM drive rests in a 5-1/4 drive bay that also includes a
front USB connection (it's an Antec USB panel product, and I noticed
there were internal mounting ears for mounting a HD to it, so that's
where I mounted my backup drive). The USB panel/drive mount adapter
includes slots on the front for air to enter/exit, but up high in the
case where it's mounted, it's difficult to get air to move. I may try
one of those HD coolers I've seen at a few sites. I might also try
changing my fan arrangement to only draw air into the cabinet (reverse
all my fans so all blow out).
--
Best regards,
Kyle
"Kylesb" <me@privacy.net> wrote in message
news:c5l6or$2jjqr$1@ID-57815.news.uni-berlin.de...
| Just goes to show that everyone will offer their opinion which are
| typically based on a very small sample set of experiences. In my
| experience, I've had 2 drives fail, a Seagate (1 gig) and an IBM GXP
| drive (20 gig). Nary a failure with many Quantum, WD, and Maxtor
| drives. But a sample set of approximately 20-30 (my experiences)
out
| of the hundreds of millions of drives produced does not yield valid
| statistical data.
|
| --
| Best regards,
| Kyle
| "KJ" <here@there.net> wrote in message
| news:Filfc.471609$Po1.204756@twister.tampabay.rr.com...
| | reliable??? Seagate
| |
| | I'd never use 'reliable' and WD in the same sentence in a positive
| light.
| |
| | "3in4" <husker3in4@donotspam.yahoo.com> wrote in message
| | news:qv1r705ov5fd5rfrom3a7cduql6o532m5f@4ax.com...
| | > Spped and reliability are in question. Need to buy a 160gb SATA
| drive for
| | my new system. Both are in the sub $120 range.
| | > Please let me know ur thoughts.
| | >
| | > Dennis
| | >
| |
| |
|