The PSU "tier" list here is not entirely accurate as it is somewhat subjective. Therefore, it is recommended that reference to good reviews of PSU's be made that do a thorough job by testing PSU's with varying loads and that do a close examination of the internal components of PSU's.
A good PSU is considered to be when it -
uses high quality components at high ratings
is assembled properly
is an efficient design
performs well with stable and clean voltage outputs
Some 500W (or greater) quality PSU's to be considered (and only those that have detailed reviews/information available) -
XFX Pro 550
SeaSonic M12II 620
SeaSonic S12II 520
Rosewill Capstone 550
Antec HCG-520M
SeaSonic M12II 520
SeaSonic S12II 620
Antec HCG-520
SeaSonic S12G-550
XFX XTR 550
Antec HCG-620M