Don't use "Apple Partition Map" - that is only for earlier (PPC) Macs.
If the disk is only for use on your Mac use 1. GUID Partition Map. You will then want to create a single HPFS partition. As already said, if the disk is to be used with a PC as well use 2. Master Boot Record and create a single ex-FAT partition.
Further deatails: https://support.apple.com/kb/PH22240?locale=en_US