Of course if you suck at gaming, refresh rate won't matter one hill a beans.
Mobius, I thank you for your fervent support of CRTs. I'll bet you still have one, which explains your loyalty. I've had both. Gamed with both. CRTs have a higher refresh rate, true, but I like the vivid colors on an LCD better. Question is therefore: which will help you game better? Your game may run smoother on CRT, perhaps you think you can perceive it. You may even be right. I tend to think all the smoothness in the world won't matter to my gaming if I have to squint to make out the enemy. A problem I don't suffer from on LCD. And I perceive my LCD to be just as smooth, because I can not tell the difference beyond a certain refresh rate anyways.
Just my two cents worth.