buffalo chicken dip is a strong choice, it seems most people dip tortilla chips in it but I prefer some sort of bread, perhaps a fresh bread roll ripped in to small pieces... some of my other favorites are:
pierogies with butter & onions (some might not know about these, it's a big thing here in pittsburgh, originating in poland, i think it's one of their "national dish's")
grilled cheese sandwich with tomato soup
lobster
any sort of plain pasta with butter & parmesan cheese
any sort of toasted sandwich (i.e. toasted ham & cheese)