• Enter here for a chance to win a custom MechWarrior 5: Mercenaries themed PC powered by Intel!

News Windows Defender Gets Perfect Scores in Antivirus Test

velocityg4

Illustrious
Windows Defender has been doing quite well at AV- Comparatives for a while now. It's convinced me to use it in my computers using a free anti-virus. As they kept up the good results rather than it being a fluke.

It's downside being overly aggressive with false positives. It's better than the daily ads of other AV. Even worse someone like Avast who keeps installing extra free security junk with every program update.

I still use a paid anti-virus for my main computers. Partly because I have a five year license for five computers. Everything else uses Defender now. If the Defender track record holds when my license expires. I'll rotate those computers to Defender as well.
 
Last edited:

bloodroses

Distinguished
Jan 27, 2013
671
14
19,165
56
Thats nice. Windows Defender has never found or stopped any viruses or malware. But Avast and Malwarebytes has.
I've had Defender find a few viruses before. For the most part it has worked quite well and is light on resources. It is currently the main AV I use with my own equipment. I also try to maintain good browsing habits and use Linux (or a VM) if I intend to go someplace questionable.

With Avast I kept getting false positives; along with AVG and Avira. You'll definitely want to keep stuff backed up since those will remove files on you with or without your permission.

Norton, McAfee, Trend Micro, and NOD32 I stopped using a long time ago.

Bitdefender, Kaspersky, and Panda I've had good luck with. I have Kaspersky on my parents machine.

Malwarebytes works quite well for me (a couple false positives though). Honestly, I never expected AV programs to act as malware removal so it is always on my and parents machines along with Sophos anti-rootkit.
 
Last edited:

velocityg4

Illustrious
I've had Defender find a few viruses before. For the most part it has worked quite well and is light on resources. It is currently the main AV I use with my own equipment. I also try to maintain good browsing habits and use Linux (or a VM) if I intend to go someplace questionable.

With Avast I kept getting false positives; along with AVG and Avira. You'll definitely want to keep stuff backed up since those will remove files on you with or without your permission.

Norton, McAfee, Trend Micro, and NOD32 I stopped using a long time ago.

Bitdefender, Kaspersky, and Panda I've had good luck with. I have Kaspersky on my parents machine.

Malwarebytes works quite well for me (a couple false positives though). Honestly, I never expected AV programs to act as malware removal so it is always on mine and parents machines along with Sophos anti-rootkit.
I always keep Malwarebytes handy. I've never looked at it as an anti-virus. More of a cure. I use an anti-virus to prevent infection. I use Malwarebytes if something gets through to wipe it out. For my computers it's just double checking manually. I can't recall the last time malware ever got through. But I do wipe out a lot of malware on clients computers with it.

Kaspersky was good and I used it for a while. It's ratings slipped for a while and they had a larger impact on system resources than others. For paid I switched to Avira. They had an excellent record. That automatically removing a file is annoying though. It's really annoying with some game mods.

I once asked a forum question regarding AV before, and it seems @Eximo was correct. With so many AVs in the market, sometimes it gets very confusing which one is the best.

Sorry to go Off topic though. I will try using Windows Defender once again:

https://forums.tomshardware.com/threads/best-antivirus-software.3487457/
There really isn't a best. The top spot changes quarterly as new results come out. Just stick with one with a consistently high rating and low resource impact. The most important protection is the user following safe computing practices.
 
Reactions: Metal Messiah.

Eximo

Titan
Ambassador
I've been using Windows Defender since Windows 7. I think I've been infected once.

I can only recall one time Windows defender actually catching something on its way in.

Even my father hasn't had issues in years which I relayed in the other post. And that is saying something, it used to be once every few months I would spend an entire evening cleaning the system up. Those websites are still pure evil. I can't imagine the sheer cost in man hours places like that waste every year. And then there are the 'driver' websites, and such, not sure why they are allowed to exist.

It is that or people finally figured out there is more money in data mining than malware/adware.
 

daglesj

Distinguished
Jul 14, 2007
485
21
18,785
0
Defender is okay, I use it. They all get beat so there is no perfect AV out there, mainly just annoying ones filled with junk.

To be honest switch to a standard user account for day to day use and that takes care of most of it. MS really needs to move away from admin accounts being the default especially for Windows 10 home.
 

A Stunned Wookie

Reputable
Sep 2, 2015
16
0
4,520
1
This doesn't surprise me. I got several trojan's a while back that Avast couldn't pick up and stumped my system. I had to do a windows reinstall and it wasn't until then that windows defender picked it up(I had it disabled so Avast could take priority).

Malewarebytes took care of the rest since the trojan wasn't letting me download any new antiviruses(it was selectively blocking downloads that would harm it) and had no choice but to run malewarebytes via a "masked" method to get it to download and get rid of the infection.
 

pjmelect

Distinguished
I am another one that uses windows defender and Malwarebytes free. Windows defender is hassel free and Malwarebytes is the best program at actually removing a virus. I stoped using the other anti virus programs because of to many false positives.
 

ASK THE COMMUNITY