• Happy holidays, folks! Thanks to each and every one of you for being part of the Tom's Hardware community!

XB271HU vs PG279Q vs S2716DG

jamison_j_b

Prominent
Feb 15, 2017
1
0
510
I am building a new rig, and I'm starting from scratch (getting new hardware, KB, mouse, monitors, router/switch SOHO, etc.). For the past 24 hours I have been going through and reading forums, watching youtube, and getting all the info I could find, as well as racking my brain. I am looking at a dual monitor setup.

I am looking at the Acer XB271HU, Asus PG279Q, and the Dell S2716DG. In the long scheme, I'm looking for a monitor that supports G-Sync. I will primarily be gaming, but I will also be using virtualization (VMware Workstation), reading e-books (primarily IT related), and transcoding A/V (DVDs and Blu-Rays). All of these things can be done with either a TN or IPS panel. I love the idea of a IPS panel, but the flickering, dead pixels, and IPS glow have me very concerned. I do know that Acer and Asus both have bad quality control. I also read that the Acer XB271HU uses a better panel from AUO and hence has less IPS glow (don't know how true that is).

At first the Dell S2716DG seemed like a safe bet, and I was about to pull the trigger, but I wanted to get user experiences (in 2017) first. I also know that all three companies have horrendous customer service.

Right now I'm using a Acer P235H, been using that for 8 years with no issues. So I am use to regular TFT LCD, but dear god IPS looks good (minus losing the display lottery, which also makes me hesitate on Acer and Asus)

Am I safe going with Acer or Asus (and which according to user experience), or should I go with the Dell?
 
The Acer XB271HU uses a very similar if not the same panel that is used in the PG279Q. If you really wanted an IPS panel I Would personally go for the Acer. It's a newer revision than the PG279Q and to be honest the extra money isn't really worth it, all the technical specs are the same.
From what I've heard the Dell uses a very good quality TN panel, but won't look as good as the other too. You also won't have to worry about IPS Glow, though it isnt something that everyone finds annoying as most people don't find it unless they use it in a dark room or go looking for it