Asus cards are oddball. There's several years where even if seriously solid performance, and quiet, the results always put them in the mid-low end of the premium brands. And some years their cards can't be caught by anyone.
Gigabyte usually is #1 or #2, same with MSI, their best is top line, but can come at an auditory cost. Gigabytes tend to sacrifice audible performance for visual performance. But the same can be said for Zotac and several others.
I've not used anything branded Gigabyte in over 15 years, the last being a lga775 mobo, that's personal preference, but you'll find most pro reviewers almost universally will use an Auros Master mobo in test benches over Asus ROG or MSI Godlike, so they must be doing something right.
Is the Aorus Extreme good? Yes, it is.