Question 5600xt only recognizing one display

[G.russell10]

Hello,

System Specs:
3600x
5600xt
b550
16gb RAM
Problem:
Whenever I turn on my PC, I only get one display. I have two monitors so one, usually the HDMI connected one, does not show anything and displays "no signal". If I unplug the monitor connected through DP, the HDMI monitor will receive a signal. Strangely, if I set my monitors to clone, they both show a display, and the second monitor shows a display. Additionally, the second monitor is picked up by Radeon Software but not Windows. Additionally, If I take the monitor out of clone mode, it will only receive a signal if it is in AMD Eyefinity mode (both monitors act as one).
Attempted Solutions:
All I have tried so far is plugging them in individually

 

[clutchc]

What do you mean by "the second monitor is picked up by Radeon Software but not Windows "? In Windows/Display, does it only show one monitor at the top? What options (If any) are available further down in 'Multiple Displays'?

Can you use HDMI or DP for both monitors?