All pretty erroneous conclusions: twice the cores and cache in one CCD would also be about twice the size, which keeps power density about exactly the same as having two smaller CCDs next to each other but would eliminate the CCD-to-CCD latency when threads that would be on different CCDs need to talk to each other,
Yes if there is zero size improvement from going to a smaller node then it would be twice the size which would be even worse for AMD...
The inter CCD latency makes zero difference to things like cinebench or video transcoding since you send the workload to the cores once and get the result, the cores don't talk to each other.
The power density also makes zero difference to how much power the platform can provide, that would be a concern on how to cool it if you could give it more power.
With twice as many cores to pick from without having to worry about CCD-to-CCD latency, there are also twice as many cores to bin for more efficient boost. The single-threaded performance should be mostly unchanged while multi-threaded throughput should be better for the same power.
That would matter to manual extreme overclockers, and to put "matter" into perspective it would be like maybe a 100Mhz difference at insane power draws.
For normal people using default settings everybody would get the same amount of max single threaded clock and it would be the one warranted by AMD.
Yes, multi-threaded throughput would be better for the same power, but how much?! If 100% more cores only get you 20-30% more multi-threaded throughput,because the new cores are 30-40% more efficient(just a random guess, did we get any leaks about this? ) , would that be good enough to get sales?!
The main reason not to do it is to let mainstream stagnate at 6-8 cores for a few more years. 2008-2017 was the age of "four cores is good enough", now we are in the 2018-2025 age of "eight cores is good enough"
Ahh, so now holding back is a good thing because AMD is doing it?!
If anyone could get a CPU out with 100% more performance at the same price they would sell gangbusters ,no matter if people need it or not, they would upgrade just because it exists.