Anyone own the Logitech F310 or F710?

[RBrim08]

I'm thinking about picking up this controller to replace my ancient wired 360 controller. I wanted to ask about the A, B, X, Y and forward shoulder buttons. Do they all press down hard and "pop" like the 360 controller? Or are they soft, gentle compressions like that of the PS3 controller?

 

[tinyE]

I've got a Logitech Cordless Rumble pack that looks almost identicle to the two you mentioned, and it is the same maker, and the shoulder buttons are very smooth. The other buttons have a slight pop but nothing more than what the old NES controllers had.

 

[RBrim08]

Well, my main concern is wear. The buttons on my 360 controller easily get stuck in the depressed position and makes tapping them a pain sometimes, because it might no register or it'll register another button instead.

The PS3 buttons don't have that problem, to my knowledge.

 

[tinyE]

Durability is the number one thing I look for because I beat the piss out of my controllers. I've had 2 of these rumble pads. The 1st one I spilled Coke on, making the buttons stick, and I had to open it up and clean it out at which point it was fine. Fine untill a week later, my Lou Brock autographed baseball rolled off my bookcase, fell 5 feet, and landed directly on the fancy little Logitech logo on the middle of the pad. The pad was toast.

I immediatly ordered a new one. That was four years ago and I havn't had a problem since.

ps I honestly think Lou Brock's autograph was the deciding factor. Had it been Ricky Henderson autograph I'm sure the pad wouldn't have broken!

 

[Basskay]

I have an F310, and the buttons are definitely more "poppy". I just got it fairly recently, and I haven't used it much, so I can't say much for their overall durability, unfortunately.