Archived from groups: microsoft.public.windowsxp.newusers (
More info?)
Thanks Sharon
You said
"But you won't be able to take out an XP drive and simply drop it into
another system. A few reasons: If using the XP boot manager, all boot
records (Win98 and XP) will be on C: There will be no boot records on
the E: drive"
So can the boot be on E:? What if in the future I just want to delete
all reference to 98se on C and make the computer just XP and remove
the C drive would I still have to do a repair.
Would a better way to go be to set up a ew partion on the main drive
and install XP system there with all the programs on the new drive?
Could I then just reinstall XP on the E drive in the future if I
wanted to abandon 98?
On Sat, 21 Aug 2004 17:57:09 -0500, Sharon F <sharonfDEL@ETEmvps.org>
wrote:
>On Sat, 21 Aug 2004 19:43:50 GMT, GTT wrote:
>
>> So John How is the best way to load XP.
>>
>> Would I start the computer with 98se and then allow the xp cd to auto
>> load or what?
>>
>> I'm thinking that if I was to request a clean install versus an
>> upgrade it might overwrite my 98se. How do I make sure xp gets loaded
>> on the E drive.
>>
>
>I would start with Win98se already installed. You can start XP setup from
>within Win98. When asked if you want to upgrade or perform a clean install,
>choose clean install. Later in setup, you will be asked where to install XP
>- select your E: drive.
>
>The XP boot manager will be installed during this process. After XP is
>installed and when you boot the system, you'll get a menu asking which
>Windows you want to load: 98 or XP.
>
>> I would actually prefer to use NTFS and thought that I would still be
>> able to read the data files. I had read somewhere that if one computer
>> on a network had NTFS and another Fat 32 then you could still see and
>> deal with data files between the 2 computers. Was this wrong?
>
>Over a network, a Win98 system can connect to an XP system and read files
>stored on an NTFS drive. On a local machine, both operating systems
>installed on a single computer, Win98 will not be able to do this.
>
>>
>> What Boot manager can someone recommend I was thinking of getting
>> Partition Magic. I think it will allow operation of different os.
>
>You could use a third party boot manager if you wanted to but it's not
>necessary since XP will manage all of this on a dual boot system.
>
>I noticed another flaw in your plans from your first post:
>
>> Have a seperate registry for each system on each hard drive so if I
>> wanted to take the hard drive out and instal it in a new computer it
>> would simply work the same as if I did that now with my present drive.
>
>The separate registries you're looking for are going to occur- each stored
>on the same partition as the respective Windows. With a few minor
>workarounds, the Win98 drive could be transferred. But you won't be able to
>take out an XP drive and simply drop it into another system. A few reasons:
>
>If using the XP boot manager, all boot records (Win98 and XP) will be on C:
>There will be no boot records on the E: drive
>
>HAL (Hardware abstraction layer), hardware enumeration and other challenges
>in configuration: Expect to run a repair install to work out these issues.
>
>The first time that I replaced a motherboard on an XP system (all other
>hardware the same including CPU), I allowed a first boot and the system
>would not start. Had to resort to a clean install to sort that mess out.
>Some folks have reported swapping boards with no problems but if you do run
>into one, there's not much recourse unless you can go back to old hardware,
>restore an image and try again.
>
>When I moved the installation to new hardware (new cpu, new motherboard and
>other various new hardware), I didn't allow a first boot and instead ran a
>repair install immediately. Reapplied updates. All worked out fine.
>
>Some references for you:
>How to Perform an In-Place Upgrade (Reinstallation) of Windows XP
>http://support.microsoft.com/default.aspx?scid=kb;EN-US;315341
>
>NOTE: The above article applies to retail CD or a generic OEM CD. If your
>Windows came preinstalled and your recovery media has been customized by
>the manufacturer, check your system manual for restore/repair options and
>for directions.
>
>And from MVP Michael Stevens:
>Changing a Motherboard or Moving a Hard Drive with XP Installed
>http://www.michaelstevenstech.com/moving_xp.html
>
>Another point: Part of XP's activation schema is to track the hardware its
>installed on. When you drop that drive into another system, you're going to
>trigger WPA (would be very surprised if you didn't). This is not a big
>problem, just re-activate. You may have to call instead of doing it online.
>Try online first.