McHenryB :
Mastermmm :
... it tells me it cannot do so, something along the lines of being 'invalid'.
It would be helpful to have the exact error message.
I highly doubt the error message would help your response. It was very general, with no numbers or codes to display. Just something along the lines of the HDD being invalid. Nonetheless, I figured out how to solve the issue! It just needed to be reformatted as Mac OS Journaled, then from there I was able to format it to exFAT.