The old memory has never been tested with the new memory, so there are no guarantees they will work together.
If your using two kits of the BLS2K8G4D240FSA, memory manufacturers don't guarantee combining multiple kits will work together.
Adding extra memory causes additional stress on the memory controller which can cause the memory to be unable to operate at its rated specifications.
Workarounds to get multiple kits of memory to work include:
Lower memory frequency
Relax DRAM timings
Increase DRAM voltage
Lower CPU multiplier