[SOLVED] crucial p1 vs bx500 vs mx500 (500gb)

[celestialus]

So i cant decide which one to choose. The costs are

p1: 75 euros
bx500: 69 euros
mx500: 76 euros

i have msi b450m pro vdh max and ryzen 5 2600 . I was gonna go for p1 but i hear that isnt gonna last long. So which one do you recommend ?

 

[mdd1963]

It would be hard to say that a SATA drive would match an NVME drive in common read speeds (rated for 2000 MB/sec, btw)....; as the NVME P1 is a dollar cheaper than the excellent SATA MX500, the choice seems clear...

Take the P1.

 

[celestialus]

Well the thing is i read about p1 not gonna live as long as mx500 cause p1 has qlc and mx500 has tlc . And in larger files p1 seems to struggle and halfway thtough the moving of a file the speed drops down really low 100mb/s for example. Im not gonna move files so much so i dont know.The mx500 seems like the safer choice but i want more opinions.