News Gaming mini-PC looks like a laptop without a screen — AtomMan G7 Ti packs Core i9-14900HX CPU, RTX 4070 Mobile GPU, and up to 96GB RAM

Status
Not open for further replies.
Article states DDR5 6500 multiple places which is just a transpose as it's 5600.

I'm really curious what these types of devices will end up looking like when CAMM modules have more general availability. I'd be really tempted to get something like this as a low power consumption gaming system if it could support higher speed DRAM.
 

kealii123

Proper
Nov 3, 2023
96
51
110
Article states DDR5 6500 multiple places which is just a transpose as it's 5600.

I'm really curious what these types of devices will end up looking like when CAMM modules have more general availability. I'd be really tempted to get something like this as a low power consumption gaming system if it could support higher speed DRAM.
The cheapest RTX 4070 laptops are under $1100 right now. Very unlikely this will be anywhere near that price.

Unless they offer a significant value over a traditional clamshell laptop I just don't see the point of these.

I would think that a mini PC with a laptop CPU in essentially an eGPU enclouser that allows for smaller form factor desktop GPUs would be a better consumer product. I get that this kinda exists with external Occulink adapters, but they are all clunky, made up of several different parts, bring-your-own-power-supply affiars that don't fully enclose the GPU.

Maybe a slim as possible mini PC, not unlike this, that has a GaN power supply for the desktop GPU and use an in-house branded GPU with a blower cooler, or even an offset cooler, to reduce the footprint. IDK if that could ever get price competitive with a laptop, when the cheapest RTX 4090 laptops are under $3k and will perform as well as a 4080 desktop for most workloads & gaming.
 
The cheapest RTX 4070 laptops are under $1100 right now. Very unlikely this will be anywhere near that price.

Unless they offer a significant value over a traditional clamshell laptop I just don't see the point of these.
Minisforum pricing is usually comparative to equivalent hardware laptop pricing. It's the big name manufacturers who always fleece for the minipcs which I've never quite understood for exactly the reason you state.

That being said a 14900HX/4070 laptop is more like $1700+ still so there's a lot of room for them to undercut not that they will. If it's anything like the Intel 11th Gen/3070 one they did the pricing will be about the same as a laptop or a bit higher than the lowest available. The time to get one of these would be when they're closing them out as that Intel one I mentioned went for around $800 when it was still competitive.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ThomasKinsley

t3t4

Prominent
Sep 5, 2023
144
55
660
Finally, they're beginning to finally think about making what I've been wanting for far too long now. I don't need/want the mouse/screen/keyboard, I only want the motherboard with desktop chip cooling, in a small box. None of these mini-PC's to date have any GPU power, but laptops do! I'm still thinking about just building my own to finally get what I want, but I cringe at the thought of paying for a bunch of hardware I don't need just to get the one part I do need.

But unless they put some real desktop chip coolers in there somewhere, it's just going to be another obnoxious oven with tiny little baby fans that cry all day long!

Thermal throttle is never an acceptable condition, let alone an option! My 12th gen i9 will thermal throttle just simply opening a web browser.... Unacceptable! Yeah, I still probably have to build my own to finally get what I want, none of these manufacturers seem willing to do what it takes to pack top of the line hardware into a small box AND keep it cool enough without using obnoxious little baby fans that just make my ears bleed. But it is nice to see that someone is finally beginning to think in this direction.
 

pixelpusher220

Distinguished
Jun 4, 2008
220
105
18,760
The cheapest RTX 4070 laptops are under $1100 right now. Very unlikely this will be anywhere near that price.

Unless they offer a significant value over a traditional clamshell laptop I just don't see the point of these.

I would think that a mini PC with a laptop CPU in essentially an eGPU enclouser that allows for smaller form factor desktop GPUs would be a better consumer product. I get that this kinda exists with external Occulink adapters, but they are all clunky, made up of several different parts, bring-your-own-power-supply affiars that don't fully enclose the GPU.

Yeah, all the portability with none of the actual 'portable' use. A *slight* improvement over NUC type form factors with the actual GPU but that seems about it to me.
 

truerock

Distinguished
Jul 28, 2006
327
45
18,820

fla56

Distinguished
Jul 19, 2006
16
5
18,515
The cheapest RTX 4070 laptops are under $1100 right now. Very unlikely this will be anywhere near that price.

Unless they offer a significant value over a traditional clamshell laptop I just don't see the point of these.

I would think that a mini PC with a laptop CPU in essentially an eGPU enclouser that allows for smaller form factor desktop GPUs would be a better consumer product. I get that this kinda exists with external Occulink adapters, but they are all clunky, made up of several different parts, bring-your-own-power-supply affiars that don't fully enclose the GPU.

Maybe a slim as possible mini PC, not unlike this, that has a GaN power supply for the desktop GPU and use an in-house branded GPU with a blower cooler, or even an offset cooler, to reduce the footprint. IDK if that could ever get price competitive with a laptop, when the cheapest RTX 4090 laptops are under $3k and will perform as well as a 4080 desktop for most workloads & gaming.
Er 14th Gen Intel? Good luck
 

fla56

Distinguished
Jul 19, 2006
16
5
18,515
Finally, they're beginning to finally think about making what I've been wanting for far too long now. I don't need/want the mouse/screen/keyboard, I only want the motherboard with desktop chip cooling, in a small box. None of these mini-PC's to date have any GPU power, but laptops do! I'm still thinking about just building my own to finally get what I want, but I cringe at the thought of paying for a bunch of hardware I don't need just to get the one part I do need.

But unless they put some real desktop chip coolers in there somewhere, it's just going to be another obnoxious oven with tiny little baby fans that cry all day long!

Thermal throttle is never an acceptable condition, let alone an option! My 12th gen i9 will thermal throttle just simply opening a web browser.... Unacceptable! Yeah, I still probably have to build my own to finally get what I want, none of these manufacturers seem willing to do what it takes to pack top of the line hardware into a small box AND keep it cool enough without using obnoxious little baby fans that just make my ears bleed. But it is nice to see that someone is finally beginning to think in this direction.
Er baby fans are the problem -try failing CPU?

Are you sure you want this??
 
Status
Not open for further replies.