johnsonma :
While relegating it to the states is a feasible option I disagree with anything that suggests a private entity could function in this kind of setting. How could you make money helping people after a disaster?
Wow! Stating that suggests you believe the government actually provides all the disaster relief in America. Hahaha! I guess that you never knew Blackwater (Yes, the same Blackwater used by the US government in the Middle East for private security forces) used their own helicopters to get people off their roofs after Hurricane Katrina. There are, literally, hundreds of private disaster relief companies, here's a
link to very short and partial list. As far as making money goes, most private disaster relief companies are non-profit.
Before the federal government got into he business of providing social assistance, disaster relief, and/or emergency services, it was a combination of private, state, and volunteer organizations that provided all of those things. You can actually graph the reduction in the number of private entities and volunteer organizations over the past 100 years as the federal government increased their scope and size in providing more and more of these services.
johnsonma :
The other thing I think is important to note is that if it was delegated to the states there would be less resources available to deal with a situation. Lets face it, the federal government has more manpower and logistical options available to them. If you divide up the money we currently devote to the disaster agencies to the states then doesn't that short change the states that deal with this kind of situation more often?
The federal government does not necessarily have more resources as much as it is they have a different pool of resources. Federal employees live somewhere right? Are they any more or less available if a disaster happens in their own home state? Are they any more or less available if their own home is destroyed?
There is also mutual aid between states. If a disaster occurs in North Carolina, the governor gets on the phone and calls the governors of South Carolina, Virginia, Georgia, West Virginia, Kentucky, Tennessee and asks for their resources and man power. Research Executive Order 13528 which establishes the Council of Governors; which is probably one of the few good things to come out of the 2008 NDAA. This type of mutual aid for disaster relief is something that could also be managed through the National Governors Association. Between these two outlets, it could enable the governors of each state to coordinate and share resources in case of disaster without the need for FEMA or other federal resources. As far as the money is concerned, if the states can share resources, who's to say they can't share the monies between them as well.