You have to understand that a 1200W PSU draws only as much as required. If your system requires 200W at idle and your PSU is 80% efficient, then it will draw (200/80 * 100) which is 250W. If your batteries are 4-5 years old, then I'd be surprised if the UPS passes the battery test. Instead of conecting your system, connect something else like a 100W light bulb and see if the UPS stays powered up for at least an hour. I have a Smart-UPS 1000 and a Smart-UPS 1500 and they can run for at least 1/2 hour when my systems are idle (except the 1500 that shutdown within a couple seconds when there was a power outage and the batteries were at least 3-4 years old, but that's normal). You can buy 8A batteries, but you probably won't find 14A batteries at that size and characteristics; even if you did, I certainly wouldn't recommend that you do since the UPS wasn't designed for those.