Review HostGator VPS and Shared Hosting Review

Surely this is a thinly-veiled ad?

Anyway, +1 for OVH. We've used them for a couple of years. Free DDoS protection that works really well (we've watched it in action a few times now) and very cheap. I don't think we've had a single downtime in 5+ years of 3x VPS's, I love 'em.
 
Surely this is a thinly-veiled ad?

Anyway, +1 for OVH. We've used them for a couple of years. Free DDoS protection that works really well (we've watched it in action a few times now) and very cheap. I don't think we've had a single downtime in 5+ years of 3x VPS's, I love 'em.
Having scanned the review, other than the intro, I'm not sure which part of this would qualify as being an advertisement or sponcon. This is a subject that the "Powers That Be" would like to see covered, and Avram has been working to figure this out. There are benchmarks, the overall rating of HostGator is quite mediocre, and both the good and bad are discussed.

We do recognize that testing web hosting companies can be complex and difficult. Avram is still giving it a shot, with help from a freelancer. Future is paying for the hosting packages. Will it end up being financially beneficial? That remains to be seen, but HostGator most certainly did not pay us to have a review saying their VPS product is often mediocre overpriced, but that shared hosting actually did pretty well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: iLoveThe80s
Could be that a huge hostgator banner in the homepage of the site may be misinterpred as an ad. It even has the price clearly stated.
Yeah, and I do recognize that fact. I've suggested we need a different image at the very least. Problem is finding a good image to convey "web hosting review of [company X]" where there's not really a physical product to photograph. But let me try to get something else in there...
 
The article neglects to mention several important things.

First, the $4.50 per month price for the shared "Baby" plan is a "teaser" rate for new customers. And to get it, you'd need to pay for three years up front. The price goes up to $6.00 per month if you're only willing to pay for one year. And if you want to try it for only one month, the price is $13.95.

Once that initial term is over, the price goes up. A lot. If you're willing to pay for three more years up front, it will cost $15 per month. For one year, it's $17 per month. And if you want to pay one month at a time, it's $22! This excessive renewal price, which Hostgator raised enormously last year, is one reason I moved my Web sites after 17 years with Hostgator. (Since this post is not an ad, I won't mention where I moved them.)

Second, while the article briefly mentions that Hostgator is owned by Newfold Digital, it doesn't explain what that actually means. Newfold Digital is the successor to Endurance International Group (EIG). EIG's business model involved buying up dozens of hosting companies, gutting them, moving their accounts to heavily-loaded centralized data center, and leaving the shell of the former hosting company as a "brand." They also spent heavily on promotion and "affiliate" marketing. Numerous sites purporting to review hosting companies and help you choose the "best" are bogus, and intended to steer people to EIG "brands."

Newfold Digital is owned by two private equity firms. One of them acquired EIG; the other owned web.com. They merged EIG and web.com to form Newfold. They also seem to have abandoned EIG's "engulf and devour" business model. They have closed many EIG "brands" to new customers, referring them to Bluehost, Hostgator, or web.com. Private equity is entirely about maximizing short-term gain for its partners and investors. One way they do that is to minimize costs. When it comes to hosting, that means cramming as many users as possible onto overloaded servers, and outsourcing technical and customer support to contractors in countries with low-cost labor, such as India and the Philippines. The most accurate way to look at it is that Newfold Digital is not in the hosting business. Hosting is strictly a source of revenue for their investment business.

That explains the mediocre performance noted in the article. Many hosting companies go into great detail about their servers and data centers. But if you look at Hostgator's Web site, you won't find any information about their infrastructure or data center. They apparently don't want you to know the truth, that if you keep your Web site with them after the initial "teaser" term, you're paying a premium for mediocre performance and less-than-mediocre support.

To summarize, you can easily find hosting companies not owned by Newfold Digital or by private equity that offer better performance and value for money than Hostgator. I found the new home for my Web sites through the "Web Hosting Talk" forums, but there are other ways. Just don't trust Web sites devoted to reviewing hosting companies, since most of their recommendations are based on generous "affiliate" payments from companies like Hostgator.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Vanderlindemedia
I was about to write ... A hosting company review on a tech site that pretty much never had covered actual hosting (benchmarks) ?

I find it weird; hosting is not just a VPS or a shared hosting account. It takes quite the (additional) software in order to properly work with it. Think of front-end like Directadmin or Cpanel, Litespeed for it's performance, but also server side security and things like that.

Your own VPS if you don't have any experience is the dumbest thing you can do, esp when you do not know why you should not install a website under Root access on a server. People should start with the very basics, a (shared) hosting package is often more then enough and there's lots to tweak if you get into it.

A VPS is handy when you need your own configuration, have specific wishes or you need absolute performance for your application, website or services. Also note that; lots of services are overpriced, support will cost you or your paying way too much for a certain, simple website.

Esp in the wordpress business there's lots of (problematic) updates, testing, hacks, i mean sniff through any servers traffic and you'll understand that 50% of total traffic is often caused by bots on the net searching for weak installations. Since people run their website(s) and perhaps sensitive data this is a big issue.
 
The company is run by world-class a$$holes.

I have a hosting account with them, on the "baby" plan. After the introductory period, the cost jumps up to $12.99/month ($467 for 3 years).

I used their free website builder product - it lets you design up to 5 web pages. If you want more than that, you have to buy their website builder pro, for $131. I paid the $131, designed several more pages, then never used the product again.

Not quite year later, I start getting emails saying unless I pay them for another year of the website builder pro, they'll take down my website. There had been nothing in the initial signup to indicate the website builder pro was a subscription-based product or that I'd lose any pages built with it if I didn't pay a new yearly subscription fee.

I'd get a new email every couple days, demanding payment. The way they came off, it was like the mob saying, "You'd better pay us protection or your house might catch on fire or some windows might get broken." It was extortionate.

I chatted with their customer service and the agent told me that the emails I was getting probably came from imposters. So I did nothing.

Then they took down my entire website. The only thing left was a hostgator icon. World class a$$holes.

I solved that problem by re-doing the site on Wordpress.

Another thing: they serve as my domain registrar. Every time I go to renew a domain, they'll sneakily add on another three years of the hosting plan (even though I have two years left that I've already paid for) So you go to check out, the charges are like $668 for what should be a $50 purchase! So you have to go delete the three extra years of the baby plan (now priced at over $200 per year) and then check out. I'm wondering how many people checkout without deleting the spurious charges?

Then last March, I paid $100 for them to install SSL on my site. Since then, I've had mass problems with my email because the site certificate came up invalid. I've spent hours with their support, chatting, and every time was told they'd fixed the problem - but they hadn't. In the last week, I've spent several hours with their support. One told me the certificate had a missing DMARC record, and that he'd fixed it - but the problems still persisted. Then finally today, the person I chatted with told me the problem was that SSL needed to be installed - and then she did that.

And now, finally, my email works without errors. But it took them four months to install SSL on the site? World class bad customer service.

I've decided that if I have any more problems, I'm going to eat the two years of service I have left with them (worth $311) and move the site to a different hosting company.

I wouldn't recommend hostgator to my worst enemy.