Question How is reliability of mechanical hard disks these days?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the Tom's Hardware community: where nearly two million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

modeonoff

Distinguished
Jul 16, 2017
1,415
18
19,295
Hello, 20-30 years ago, hard drives failed suddenly for no reason. Usually I heard strange clicking sound and sooner or later, they suddenly failed to function. The past few years I just use SSD. How is the reliability of hard drives such as the Seagate One Touch Portable External Hard Drive? Do they fail easily and suddenly?
 
I'm not saying they should be variants of Samsung.

My point is that if you want data to be backup up which you should, you want the data to be on drives that don't have high fail rates and you want to store them on drives that last for a long time before its time to replace them.

With Samsung SSD, you're chances of losing files is very low. Doesn't change the fact that you still need to backup on other drives but its just a good idea is to backup on drives that are just reliable. Doesn't matter whether its Samsung or not.
 
I'm not saying they should be variants of Samsung.

My point is that if you want data to be backup up which you should, you want the data to be on drives that don't have high fail rates and you want to store them on drives that last for a long time before its time to replace them.

With Samsung SSD, you're chances of losing files is very low. Doesn't change the fact that you still need to backup on other drives but its just a good idea is to backup on drives that are just reliable. Doesn't matter whether its Samsung or not.
My chances of losing files is near 0%. Across all my drives and types.
I say 'near 0%', because there is always the possibility of an asteroid strike.

What do YOU use for backups, with what procedure?


 
I'm not saying they should be variants of Samsung.

My point is that if you want data to be backup up which you should, you want the data to be on drives that don't have high fail rates and you want to store them on drives that last for a long time before its time to replace them.

With Samsung SSD, you're chances of losing files is very low. Doesn't change the fact that you still need to backup on other drives but its just a good idea is to backup on drives that are just reliable. Doesn't matter whether its Samsung or not.
You also have to remember that an off-site backup is necessary to protect against fire, flood and theft. That may be a cloud backup or a physical backup kept at another location.
Data loss has MANY causes, only one of which is disk failure.
 
Yeah thanks...although I'm still not very confident that I should use HDDs instead of SDDs for this. That Seagate drive failure costed me some of my works.

Who knows how long these WD drives I have for internal and external will last...
That is why you have multiple devices and device types.
Even the magical Samsung SSDs can and do fail.
Maybe not as much as others, but by no means 0%.
 
  • Like
Reactions: WrongRookie
just one thing to think about... if a HDD fails and the data is important, you have better chance of recovering data through recovery service. I heard SSDs can be tricky to recover data. Even one automatic TRIM basically make recovery nearly impossible.