Ah. There's multiple other factors besides hardware choice. He doesn't really go into how the gpu is setup, how the airflow and ambient temps of a test bench affects the airflow and temps inside your case etc. His point isn't the actual temps the cooler is capable of, his point is the comparison between what he started out with vs what he ended up with vs how much performance gain the gpu saw and is capable of.
If stock you saw 90°C, his numbers would show you'd be closer to 70°C ish with the upgrade. That just says you have an extra 20°C to play with, not that you will hit the 67°C he did etc.
On a test bench, assume the room is a more comfortable 20°C. The inside of your case will be closer to 30°C. You cannot cool an object below ambient temp by mechanical means. It's impossible. You can't blow 30°C air through a rad and expect the gpu to be at 20°C. Only a chemical process like phase change, LN2, peltier etc is capable of that feat. So idle at best will be closer to 30°C no matter what his video shows. You'd have to mount that aio as intake and be using 20°C air to lower the gpu temp at idle, but even then the gpu has its limits, it's electronic and gives off a certain amount of heat.
Your temps went down. That's the purpose of the better cooling. Not matching a pc that's setup and tested differently to yours.
Also have to figure fan speed. Unless you manually set the fan speed for 100% (not pump), your fan will be controlled by the cpu temp, since it's on the cpu header. So fan speeds will vary according to cpu loads, not gpu loads. The way around that is to use an adapter to change the mini molex the gpu uses for the stock fans and plug in the rad fan to that connection. Then the rad fan will vary in speeds according to gpu temps, not cpu temps. Then you can adjust the gpu fan curve using PrecisionX or Afterburner to get temps and curves you are comfortable having for the gpu and your usage.
You may be correct but the thing is i see multiple reviews on amazon that put the 120mm aio in the same place, can have the same mid-tower gaming case, and almost same airflow as mine, and the same ambient temp and they will never exceed 47c max. So that brought me to the conclusion that it has to be fans, thermal paste, or screws. Like it literally have almost the same idle temp AS MY FE REFERENCE COOLER. For example, this is a review i found on amazon
"OMG!!! So I was overclocking my Zotac 1080 ti Amp Edtion and was watching the temps hitting 80+ C on the GPU. That didn't sit too well with me. I watched some videos and read some reviews about this thing and most were pretty positive and their results were in the realm of "too good to be true". Even if it were true, I had all kinds of apprehensions about tearing my pricey video card apart. As it turns out, my fears were unfounded.
The instructions that came with the G12 are very generic but it clued me in well enough that I was able to decipher the rest. Installation was remarkably simpler than I expected. 5 screws is all that held the stock cooler to the card. I had to use a little wiggle action to pry the card loose from the cooler but it relented. Be careful of the wires as there are 2 of them on this card. They unplugged with little protest though. I cleaned off the mountain of old thermal paste on the GPU itself. I think they went a little overboard at the factory. Since I was installing a new AIO I didn't need to apply any new paste as it came pre-applied. The only hiccup was when I was mounting the radiator onto the rear of the case where a 120mm fan previously resided. Although the Corsair H55 included the long mounting screws for the fan, it didn't come with short screws to mount to the case on the other side. I suppose I could have put the screws through the case, then through the fan to the radiator but I preferred my led fan visible from inside the case so I can marvel at my own magnificence. I guess it was a very good thing I had bought an assortment of extra screws way back when and now that purchase has finally paid off! HA! My Corsair 400c accommodates a 240mm radiator in the front as well as a 120mm radiator in the rear. I'm glad I made that rear radiator an exhaust since the air coming out is pretty hot. Since the installation I haven't seen the GPU get any hotter than 47 degrees no matter what I do!
I think it's really up to the individual at this point. For me the stars and planets aligned and the GPU gods took pity on me and saw that I lost the GPU lottery so they blessed me with cooling. Not all video cards are made the same and I think some don't react well to being taken apart. Luckily the Zotac 1080 ti Amp Edition wasn't such a chore and my case has radiator options. The risk is great but the payoff may well be worth it."
And the pictures were literally exactly the same setup as mine, same rear aio placement, hose orientation, even the same cpu fan
And even this review
"
I've only had this up and running for a couple of days, if anything changes, I will update this review.
I installed the G12 on an Nvidia 1080ti FE. This card has a blower style stock cooler, and it's designed to run at fairly high temps (mine would idle in the 40-50C range with the blower running at low, while gaming it would be in the upper 60-70's and the fan sounded like a vacuum cleaner.
After installation, idle is pinned to the ambient air temp - 23C! After gaming for several hours, temps got into the mid 30's! I'm seeing a 30-40 degree temp drop, which is much better than expected. After gaming, I also ran some user benchmarks, and the card is running as expected, with no thermal throttling, and slightly higher frequencies (I'm voltage limited right now).
I paired this bracket with a Corsair H55, with 2 fans in a push pull configuration, I also applied heat sinks to all mosfets and memory chips, similar to the top comment, but did not use thermal pads.
Parts used in my build:
1080Ti FE
NZXT G12
Corsair H55
GPU fan adapter - lets the GPU control the H55 fan speed
Noctua NF-A12x15 PWM, 4-Pin Premium Quiet Slim Fan (comes with Y adapter, so both radiator fans can be controlled by the GPU)
Cosmos 20 PCS mini Aluminum Chips VGA RAM Cooling Heatsinks (for Mosfets)
Cosmos 8 PCS Copper VGA RAM Cooling Heatsinks (for RAM)
Cooler Master Thermal paste "
This actually worries me and pisses me off, i should be getting those temps easily and im not even sure why. AND THEIR PUMP IS EVEN AT A LOWER SPEED **** theirs is lower than 4800 RPM and MINE IS OVER 5000 RPM
I literally have a lower ambient than him WTF. I really need a find a solution, I should be getting those temps easily, so i had to install something not enough or incorrectly. And 90% of the reviews i see have under 50c temps WITH THE SAME SETUP and a 120 AIO the other 10% is not running their pump speed at 100%