Question I need help choosing between the two gpu

[DesolatedPotato]

So i'm about to buy GPU next week and I got two options

both are equivalent to 250 usd in my country.

Aorus 1080ti xtreme 11g or Aorus/Sapphire/Gigabyte Nitro 5700xt 8gb

I'm all in futureproof and performance
1080p gaming only.. or probably 1440p

I play games like monster hunter, elden ring, new world, black desert, dota 2 etc.

 

[faalin]

1080ti is around 40% better then the 5700xt. what is the rest of your system specs, make and model of PSU as well.

 

[DesolatedPotato]

1080ti is around 40% better then the 5700xt. what is the rest of your system specs, make and model of PSU as well.

Ryzen 5 5600
Asus tuf A520M
t-force 3600mhz 8x2
kingston 256gb nvme ssd
samsung 860 1tb ssd
FSP HV pro 85+ 650w

 

[faalin]

1080ti all day long, happy gaming

 

[Roland Of Gilead]

I don't think it's quite so clean cut. They both trade blows depending on the game:

RX 5700 XT Vs. GTX 1080 Ti Vs. RTX 3060 | 1080p and 1440p Gaming Benchmarks - YouTube

 

[Phaaze88]

1080ti is around 40% better then the 5700xt. what is the rest of your system specs, make and model of PSU as well.

HOW did you get 40%? The gap isn't that wide:

Spoiler

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1w9ZTmj_zX4

 

[DesolatedPotato]

HOW did you get 40%? The gap isn't that wide:

Spoiler

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1w9ZTmj_zX4

really? which one will you get if you were to ask?

 

[Phaaze88]

really? which one will you get if you were to ask?

5700XT, simply because it's newer... but these cards were really popular in mining rigs, so are we sure you're not looking at one of those?

 

[DesolatedPotato]

n

5700XT, simply because it's newer... but these cards were really popular in mining rigs, so are we sure you're not looking at one of those?

nope. most of them are first owner's trying to upgrade since the prices of newer gpu's were cut down. Most of 5700xt are probably around $230~360

 

[PsychoPsyops]

Personally I'd go with the 1080ti. Nvidia drivers may be buggy, but their hardware is more reliable than AMD's and that's what can make or break a wallet.

 

[logainofhades]

1080ti is around 40% better then the 5700xt. what is the rest of your system specs, make and model of PSU as well.

This is quite false. Unless a game heavily favored one over the other, you wouldn't ever be able to tell which one you were using.

Personally I'd go with the 1080ti. Nvidia drivers may be buggy, but their hardware is more reliable than AMD's and that's what can make or break a wallet.

More reliable? Based on what?

 

[DesolatedPotato]

This is quite false. Unless a game heavily favored one over the other, you wouldn't ever be able to tell which one you were using.

More reliable? Based on what?

which one would you prefer? I'm staying only 1080P high or ultra preset would be nice.
and if.. does 5600xt would also option incase? which costs $200 only here