[SOLVED] I5-8600 or i3-10105f ?

[Godhax]

Helou, wich one should i pick I’m in big dilemma the i5 is quicker but the i3 is newer
i will mainly play csgo,valorant,fn, etc
Both pc cost almost the same,
I do not have information about mb,psu
Ram is ddr4 2666 8gb

Pc1
Pc2

 

[Koekieezz]

Helou, wich one should i pick I’m in big dilemma the i5 is quicker but the i3 is newer
i will mainly play csgo,valorant,fn, etc
Both pc cost almost the same,
I do not have information about mb,psu
Ram is ddr4 2666 8gb

Pc1
Pc2

10105f one. you could upgrade it into i5 10400f which is the same specs as i7 8700, and up to i9 11900/10900 variants. all of the core i series have multi thread on 10th and 11th gen.

 

[geofelt]

Both are comparable.
But the i3-10105 has a slightly higher single thread passmark performance, 2713 vs. 2585 for the 8600.
Your games depend on cpu single thread performance.

And, you may want more than 8gb.

 

[--SID--]

What are the other parts in the systems? Motherboard, PSU etc. And the GTX 1650, is it GDDR5 or GDDR6?

 

[Koekieezz]

Someone -?-?-?-?

Both are comparable.
But the i3-10105 has a slightly higher single thread passmark performance, 2713 vs. 2585 for the 8600.
Your games depend on cpu single thread performance.

And, you may want more than 8gb.

10105f one. you could upgrade it into i5 10400f which is the same specs as i7 8700, and up to i9 11900/10900 variants. all of the core i series have multi thread on 10th and 11th gen.

you have your answers.

 

[Godhax]

you have your answers.

I want some more opinions, i wont upgarde this pc it should last 3-4 years after that i will buy i Another one.

 

[SkyNetRising]

wich one should i pick I’m in big dilemma the i5 is quicker but the i3 is newer

i3-10105f pc is better.

i5-8600 pc looks like it's from year 2005.
Both probably have terrible airflow and questionable PSUs in them.
i3-10105f probably is better upgradeable. Slap in a better gpu (when gpu prices/availablility improves), upgrade PSU (to meet gpu power consumption) and that pc can easily last another 10 years.

 

[geofelt]

Most pre-builts will have minimal cheap power supplies.
They are not designed to be upgraded.
Without knowing more about the power supply make/model, I would try to find a better alternative.

 

[Godhax]

i3-10105f pc is better.

i5-8600 pc looks like it's from year 2005.
Both probably have terrible airflow and questionable PSUs in them.
i3-10105f probably is better upgradeable. Slap in a better gpu (when gpu prices/availablility improves), upgrade PSU (to meet gpu power consumption) and that pc can easily last another 10 years.

Yes it looks like an old pc, but they make those pc’s like that,thats a company from Germany https://www.wortmann.de/de-at/search.aspx?q=*&category=AA_TERRA_PC
I’m not from Germany so I don’t know a lot, meybe someone here hear about theme and can share some intel

 

[Koekieezz]

you could try and see intel i3 till i9 from gen 8 and 9 specs, then compare it to 10th gen and 11th gen specs. after that compare their prices. soon you'll know why 10105f is the best choice. no matter who made the pc, you must make a asumption why any intel below 10th gen is not worth he prices today (even a used i7 8700 is still not worth it compared to i5 10400f, atleast in my country)

 

[Godhax]

you could try and see intel i3 till i9 from gen 8 and 9 specs, then compare it to 10th gen and 11th gen specs. after that compare their prices. soon you'll know why 10105f is the best choice. no matter who made the pc, you must make a asumption why any intel below 10th gen is not worth he prices today (even a used i7 8700 is still not worth it compared to i5 10400f, atleast in my country)

Your answer was very helpful thank you for your time^^