IC Diamond Test Results

Page 12 - Seeking answers? Join the Tom's Hardware community: where nearly two million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Tom's Hardware Final IC Diamond Test Results Continued -

sept302010multiforumtestupdateICDiamondvsMX2MX3.png


Sept30updateshinEtsux23.PNG


12UserTestsICDiamondComparedtoOCZ-I.png


And as we had a laptop test we will include multiforum laptop results

August212010notebookreview.png
 
Notes for observational request on IHS, This is part of the final report

I love the IC-7 paste, but has anyone had any issues with polishing?

I heard the CPU writing is removed after application and removal of IC-7.

I haven't removed it myself so I don't know how much polishing it causes...

This is part of the final report


All thermal Compounds are Polishing Compounds to some extent and a good shop practice should be obvious here to avoid overworking any compound on installation and removal by not rotating the sink under pressure or over rubbing a compound on removal and letting the cleaner do most of the work to soften the material should resolve most issues.


Aluminum oxide aka Corundum AKA Ruby and Sapphire which are used extensively in the abrasion business most commonly in sandpaper is also used extensively in thermal compounds. In general people should be careful and not overwork there compounds when installing and removing. If it is a concern use a white paste generic zinc oxide compound.

From MSDS Product Identification
Arctic Alumina Premium Thermal Compound
Product Code: AA
SECTION 2: COMPOSITION/INFORMATION ON INGREDIENTS
Product Ingredient Information CAS No.
Aluminum Oxide 1344-28-1
Boron Nitride 10043-11-5
Polyol Ester Non-hazardous
Polyether Glycol Non-hazardous

Just to note many thermal compound scan be substituted for lapping compounds and many compounds contain significant amounts of Aluminum Oxide, which is nearly as hard as diamond. Many of Arctic silver products contain it as well as other manufacturer thermal compounds . I have tested 7 other compounds on oxidized copper plate and have found them all to be approximately equivalent abrasive.

To be abrasive you just have to be harder than the copper IHS which rates near the bottom of the hardness MOHS scale.

In short nearly all thermal compounds can be defined as Lapping compounds

Aluminum Oxide is what they make sandpaper out of...

This is a common well known abrasive read the wikipedia cut, as an example check the cut from ceramiq MSDS and MOHS table of hardness

Corundum
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Corundum
General
Category Oxide mineral – Hematite group
Chemical formula Aluminium oxide, Al2O3
Strunz classification IV/C.04-10
Dana classification 4.3.1.1
Crystal symmetry Trigonal (32/m)
Unit cell a = 4.75 Å, c = 12.982 Å; Z=6
Identification
Color Colorless, gray, brown; pink to pigeon-blood-red, orange, yellow, green, blue to cornflower blue, violet; may be color zoned, asteriated mainly grey and brown
Crystal habit Steep bipyramidal, tabular, prismatic, rhombohedral crystals, massive or granular
Crystal system Trigonal (Hexagonal Scalenohedral)
Symbol (32/m)
Space group: R3c
Twinning Polysynthetic twinning common
Cleavage None – parting in 3 directions
Fracture Conchoidal to uneven
Mohs scale hardness 9
Luster Adamantine to vitreous
Streak White
Diaphaneity Transparent, translucent to opaque
Specific gravity 3.95–4.10
Optical properties Uniaxial (–)
Refractive index nω = 1.767–1.772
nε = 1.759–1.763
Pleochroism None
Melting point 2044 °C
Fusibility Infusible
Solubility Insoluble
Alters to May alter to mica on surfaces causing a decrease in hardness
Other characteristics May fluoresce or phosphoresce under UV
References [1][2][3][4]
Major varieties
Sapphire Any color except red
Ruby Red
Emery Black granular corundum intimately mixed with magnetite, hematite, or hercynite

Corundum is a crystalline form of aluminium oxide (Al2O3) with traces of iron, titanium and chromium.[1] It is a rock-forming mineral. It is one of the naturally clear transparent materials, but can have different colors when impurities are present. Transparent specimens are used as gems, called ruby if red, while all other colors are called sapphire.

The name "corundum" is derived from the Tamil word குருந்தம் "kuruntam" meaning "ruby", itself derived from the Sanskrit "kuruvinda".[3]

Because of corundum's hardness (pure corundum is defined to have 9.0 Mohs), it can scratch almost every other mineral. It is commonly used as an abrasive, on everything from sandpaper to large machines used in machining metals, plastics and wood. Some emery is a mix of corundum and other substances, and the mix is less abrasive, with a lower average hardness near 8.0.
In addition to its hardness, corundum is unusual for its density of 4.02 g/cm3, which is very high for a transparent mineral composed of the low atomic mass elements aluminium and oxygen.[5


Product Identification
Céramique High-Density Thermal Compound
Product Code: Céramique
SECTION 2: COMPOSITION/INFORMATION ON INGREDIENTS
Product Ingredient Information CAS No.
Aluminum Oxide 1344-28-1
Boron Nitride 10043-11-5
Zinc Oxide 1314-13-2
Proprietary Oil Blend Non-hazardous

TABLE 2. MOHS HARDNESSES OF SELECTED MATERIALS

Abrasive


Mohs Hardness

wax (0 deg C)


0.2

graphite


0.5 to 1

talc


1

copper


2.5 to 3

gypsum


2

aluminum


2 to 2.9

gold


2.5 to 3

silver


2.5 to 4

calcite


3

brass


3 to 4

fluorite


4

glass


4.5 to 6.5

asbestos


5

apatite


5

steel


5 to 8.5

cerium oxide


6

orthoclase


6

vitreous silica


7

beryl


7.8

quartz


8

topaz


9

aluminum oxide


9


silicon carbide (beta type)


9.2

boron carbide


9.3

boron


9.5

diamond


10


This is the final IC Diamond report although this is the end of the exercise anyone should feel free to post their results at any time, make comments or post a question. I am particularly interested in long term reliability those that keep the the compound installed for for any period of time 6months, 1-2 years etc. I have a guy @ xtremsytems @ 2years with no change in temps on several systems overclocked and folding 24/7 and would like to gather more data.

So to to close this out a little song for you. I have a guy I sponsor who is a great fan of the paste and he wrote a song about IC Diamond which is performed by his daughter on you tube. So I claim a first here- The first song ever written about a thermal compound and performed publicly.


Danielle sings IC Diamond
 
I love the IC-7 paste, but has anyone had any issues with polishing?

I heard the CPU writing is removed after application and removal of IC-7.

I haven't removed it myself so I don't know how much polishing it causes...
 


If it does, it's really no harm, so why worry?
 
IC Diamond Test Report is Final - was going to add more data but upon review too much unnecessary redundancy.

Great Job People! and thanks for all your efforts.

All the Best

Andrew
 

And thank you Andrew for making this all happen :)
 
A comparison of some results from German giveaway that dovetails nicely with the Tom's Hardware tests - it takes a couple of clicks on the pic to get the full image

The first block are the tests that experienced improvement over the installed compound. The second of 15 block at the end are those users that experienced a null result.

These are raw data results and this is the first exercise where I had zero input into the forum discussion.

Also A review of Perihelion posted

http://www.overclockerstech.com/IC-Perihelion-Thermal-Compound/3/


ic_survey_21.11.gif
 
If anybody cares I applied it to my Asus Direct CU GTX 460 TOP card and I saw a 4C drop in temp at 100% load in Furmark. I think idle was about the same as it was before.
 


Always appreciate more data


some from EVGA on graphics cards

evgaresults.png



 
Kind of a technical or troubleshooting note

We are now at 20 giveaways the most recent from OCUK with something a little different

This set of data that separates OCUK from all the 20 or so groups tested by us.

In the past water cooling is usually less than 5% of the sampled results, on OCUK at this point we are 30% water cooling(marked in red), 70% air.

What made it readily obvious was the statistical cluster of 20% water in the marginal-zero-negative result category. The other 10% is mostly the H50 in the performed as expected group. Might be linked to compound mix but I have a sense that it may have an overall edge in C/P for the H50.
In any event The air cooler group (marked blue) has it over the water with pretty much positive results across the board.




OCUKMarch27updatechart.png