I don't think this has very much to do with supply and demand. It's more of a control method to make sure that users lock into contracts with the carriers. If the off contract price is this inflated, and there's little to no discount with service costs when using an off contract phone vs a subsidized one, then it pretty much pushes everyone into purchasing carrier subsidized contract tied phones.[/quote]
Still just supply and demand. They could tue a discounted price to purchase of an an underwater basket-weaving club for all I care. It doesn't matter.
It's their product they get to ask what they want and you get to make a choice with your money.
Don't like the terms they offer?....DON"T SPEND YOUR MONEY.
The government doesn't give a damn, and instead has just made efforts to tax the unsubsidized price on the smartphones. Quite a few states have made that change recently. It's my opinion that some kind of policy change is needed to make this practice illegal, but... what can we do? The government is run by the rich for the rich.