Well when the unit blows from overloading, and takes out half your hardware with it, you'll be able to post here and tell us why wont you?
Besides when you overload something, its not as efficient meaning it burns more energy and creates a lot more heat, in turn causing it to have a short life span.
While I agree that a budget power supply can fail and cause problems, the 3870's just don't need as much power as the X2900XT's. It all depends on what else he has in his system.
quantumsheep :
I also have no idea where all this nonesense about a bad PSU taking out half a system with it. I've had about 3 PSU failures since i've been building PCs (10-15 years or so) and not one of them has ever damaged any components. All the other people i've talked to have said the same thing, that their PSU failing did not cause any collateral damage.
When I built a couple of systems last February, I took the SL-400TF PSU out of a new AM2 MSI Nvidia 6100 barebones and used it in an old Northwood system. The Northwood's Coolermaster Realpower 450 went into the new AM2 build because it's a better PSU, even though it only has 22 amps on the 12 volt rails.
Well, the budget PSU died about two months later and took the old i865 board and the X1650 Pro AGP with it before I could replace it with a better PSU. The hard drive was fine. I don't have a socket 478 spare board, so I never tested the CPU.
I took a chance instead of just putting the Northwood in the closet until I could get a better PSU. On the other hand, a friend has a RAIDMAX 350 watt PSU in his RAIDMAX case, and it's been going good for well over a year. So, you can never tell. That Sparkle PSU might just survive and not fry anything, but depending on what he has in his box, it might not have enough power for everything at load.
Now, I have an Antec Neo 550 and a Truepower 500 in my two AMD 690G AM2 systems, much more dependable than a budget PSU and the Neo was $79 at Fry's while the Truepower was $49, and they have Seasonic components. Never trust the PSU that comes with a case or a barebones unless you can handle the risk.
I also won't buy a PSU without active PFC.