Question Manli GTX 1650 vs ASUS Cerberus GTX1050ti

[cincinnatus]

Hello,

I am aware of the current market issue and that these are not amazing cards.

I am not much of a gamer,
I just want to play some genshin impact with 1080 + mid settings = 0% stutters (and without replacing the psu)
Right now to play I have to 720 + low settings = still get some stutters.

between these two which should i get?

Manli GeForce GTX 1650 GDDR6 at 290$
https://www.manli.com/en/product-detail-MANLI_GeForce_GTX_1650_GDDR6_(M1434-1+N600-01)-16.html

or

ASUS Cerberus GeForce GTX1050ti at 269$

CERBERUS-GTX1050TI-A4G - Tech Specs｜Graphics Cards｜ASUS Global

Detailed specification of CERBERUS-GTX1050TI-A4G Tech Specsï¼Graphic Engine:NVIDIA® GeForce GTX 1050 TiãGraphic Engine:NVIDIA® GeForce GTX 1050 TiãBus Standard:PCI Express 3.0ãBus Standard:PCI Express 3.0ãOpenGL:OpenGL®4.5ãOpenGL:OpenGL®4.5ãVideo Memory:4GB GDDR5ãVideo Memory:4GB...

www.asus.com

I have a preassembled HP Pavilion 500 from january 2014:
mobo: Memphis-S with Intel H87
cpu: Intel Core i7-4770
gpu: GeForce GT 640 (through PCIe v3.0 x16)
psu: pcb230 (max 300w)
ssd: samsung 250gb
ram: 16GB DDR3
display: pavilion 22xi 1080 60hz

 

[iPeekYou]

Hello,

I am aware of the current market issue and that these are not amazing cards.

I am not much of a gamer,
I just want to play some genshin impact with 1080 + mid settings = 0% stutters (and without replacing the psu)
Right now to play I have to 720 + low settings = still get some stutters.

between these two which should i get?

Manli GeForce GTX 1650 GDDR6 at 290$
https://www.manli.com/en/product-detail-MANLI_GeForce_GTX_1650_GDDR6_(M1434-1+N600-01)-16.html

or

ASUS Cerberus GeForce GTX1050ti at 269$

CERBERUS-GTX1050TI-A4G - Tech Specs｜Graphics Cards｜ASUS Global

Detailed specification of CERBERUS-GTX1050TI-A4G Tech Specsï¼Graphic Engine:NVIDIA® GeForce GTX 1050 TiãGraphic Engine:NVIDIA® GeForce GTX 1050 TiãBus Standard:PCI Express 3.0ãBus Standard:PCI Express 3.0ãOpenGL:OpenGL®4.5ãOpenGL:OpenGL®4.5ãVideo Memory:4GB GDDR5ãVideo Memory:4GB...

www.asus.com

I have a preassembled HP Pavilion 500 from january 2014:
mobo: Memphis-S with Intel H87
cpu: Intel Core i7-4770
gpu: GeForce GT 640 (through PCIe v3.0 x16)
psu: pcb230 (max 300w)
ssd: samsung 250gb
ram: 16GB DDR3
display: pavilion 22xi 1080 60hz

Check this out, shows the 1050 Ti is quite behind the 1650. 1050 Ti is nowhere close to the 1060, whereas the 1060 is close to 1650/S, RX 470, and the like.

Crikey, those prices are nuts. Used to get a 580 for $60, now all we can scrape up is this.

 

[cincinnatus]

Thanks for your answer iPeekYou.

I don't know how many views on that video are mine from last week haha.
It is a really well done comparison.

I bought a new manly Manli at 290$ this morning.
There were 4 available from a reliable ebay seller.
As soon as the first was taken, the other three were gone in less than an hour. I got myself the third one.

It should arrive this friday,
I will let you know how the manly Manli performs.

 

[cincinnatus]

I got the card today, so I'll share my findings.

playing genshin @1080, after intensive use:

mid settings:
temp max 65°
gpu use max 70%
i have seen 2 stutters in a whole hour (with stutter i mean a frame staying noticeably longer)

high settings:
temp max 74°
gpu use max 99%
i see a stutter every minute

conclusions so far:
i am happy with it,
-from low settings @720 with stutters to mid settings @1080 without
-it was the best i could get without replacing the psu
-it uses only 75w
-didn't wait for it

I have a decent graphic card now and I can't complain anymore