Motorola Close to Completing 'Project Ara' Prototype

Status
Not open for further replies.

sanctoon

Distinguished
Jul 29, 2008
77
0
18,630
0
I love the whole Phonebloks idea, do yourselves a favor and watch a few Youtube videos about it (if you haven't allready). I'm glad Phonebloks got partnered with Moto, now it actually stands a change of becoming a reality.
 

the1kingbob

Distinguished
May 27, 2011
153
0
18,680
0
Just out of curiosity, who has it failed for in the past? I think it is a fantastic idea, in reality I am pretty sure they are designing a beast of a phone and then parting it down with weaker components.
 

biohazrdfear

Honorable
Mar 1, 2013
340
0
10,860
35
There have been a few brands, but I don't really feel researching at the moment. The biggest thing is the cost of the individual parts. The phone designs are blocky and undesirable, and in a nutshell...no one will buy them.
 

doron

Distinguished
Feb 15, 2009
553
0
19,010
24


"People who say it cannot be done should not interrupt those who are doing it."
--George Bernard Shaw
 

JD88

Honorable
Feb 25, 2013
1,424
0
11,660
110


To Translate: You don't feel like researching because you know there's nothing out there that's been done before that even comes close to something like this.

I really like it when people crap all over a company trying to do something unique and innovative. Your closed minded statements sound kinda like Steve Ballmer did when he was talking about the first iPhone. The first cell phones were "blocky and undesirable" yet they have revolutionized our society. We need to recognize something as just a prototype. If we know anything about Motorola and Google it's that they know how to design a product. Just give them a chance.
 

JD88

Honorable
Feb 25, 2013
1,424
0
11,660
110


Nice try, but none of those are even remotely close to the concept mentioned here and none of them had the backing of a major corporation behind them. That Brix concept was certainly interesting though. Reminds me of the Padphone from Asus in some ways.
 

biohazrdfear

Honorable
Mar 1, 2013
340
0
10,860
35
Alright, JD, you're right in every way shape and form. Its a phone that can be taken apart and rebuilt piece by piece...the same thing with the previous phones I mentioned. But no matter, you win this argument by default since you keep objecting. Thanks, buddy. I'll still keep hold of my phones, rather than these broken "build your own" phones that never took off.
 

teh_chem

Honorable
Jun 20, 2012
902
0
11,010
17
The practical obstacles to something like this reaching the mainstream consumers are so numerous. Yeah, yeah, "if you don't want to innovate, then don't get in the way of people that do," blah, blah blah. That's not the issue. Just one factor, let's look at operating systems, like Android. Even though android has a significant number of different hardware devices to consider in terms of compatibility, does anyone think that Software QA testers are going to be available to test every different iteration/combination of hardware modules? No, in fact, most software QA for android can't even test on all the in-use devices, but rather a set of the more-popular ones, and that's about it.
 

JD88

Honorable
Feb 25, 2013
1,424
0
11,660
110


Did you even read about the phones you mentioned?

None of them were about building your own phone.

Brix was about combining multiple phones into a single screen.

http://www.ubergizmo.com/2007/08/brix-concept-phone/

Modu was about putting a phone inside other gadgets such as a car or laptop in order to give them access to basic phone functions.

http://www.cnet.com.au/modu-phone-339301382.htm
 

rwinches

Distinguished
Jun 29, 2006
888
0
19,060
30
Modular is good for repair.
Not good for upgrade.

So one piece will upgrade and the others will freeze in time and not progress?
The rare possibility of upgrading radio service like 3G to 4G yeah no.
You would change state of the art to make things swappable?
What would you swap out the screen?
The inclusion of connectors in line would never work.
The reduction in scale and the integration of discrete components into the Soc designs make this concept less likely as each day passes.
And, we haven't even factored in the consumer swapping and installing or choosing the correct module.
Sorry the time for this has passed for the smartphone.
 

alextheblue

Distinguished
Apr 3, 2001
3,078
106
20,970
2
I think it's a great idea! As long as you never, ever drop your phone. "Has anyone seen my phone's camera module? I thought I saw it slide under the water cooler but I can't find it!" ;)

It just seems odd to see something like that these days. You've got manufacturers dropping memory cards and user-serviceable batteries in the name of design... this is the complete other end of that spectrum. Don't get me wrong, I love easy-change batteries and SD card slots but... wowzers!

Anyway, I'm sure it's been brought up before but... this reminds me of DIY laptop attempts (whitebooks). I like the concept but I can't see it really taking off. Good luck Moto!
 

wtfxxxgp

Honorable
Nov 14, 2012
173
0
10,680
0
I think the concept itself is a good one. With technology we are guaranteed of one thing: progress. So it's feasible in the near future at least. If they planned their vision properly then there's no reason this shouldn't work. Whether people choose to purchase it is a completely different story. Aesthetically it ain't pretty, but then again, we are once again looking at "simple elegance" in today's phones with form being less important than function lately (finally, it IS a man's world ;)) I have to agree on the fact that it will probably flop - but that's only based on the fact that part of the desirability of phones today is in getting the latest and greatest, even if your S3 is still a powerful phone, many people have ditched it in favor of the S4. Human habits won't change, and that will be the downfall of this very practical concept.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ASK THE COMMUNITY