Rampage:
Since it has been determined that the PSU is the problem you need to stop messing around and either buy a new PSU or take out the graphics card, if you continue to run the card while it is underpowered you can damage the card, not to mention if the PSU fails from over stress there is a real chance it could take any number of hardware with it when it goes, I dont think you want this to happen, so make a choice, spend $65 on a new Antec PSU or take out the new graphics card, you need to do one of the two. If you choose to keep running the new card then be prepared to deal with the consequences.
Also I can't stress enough how important a good PSU is.
There is a HUGE difference between a good power supply like Antec and a generic piece of crap, HUGE. If you want to know why Antec is so good just go to Antecs website and start reading the technical specifications for one of their high end power supplies, you will start noticing why they are one of the best power supply makers in the world, superior design, and quality components, period.
newegg.com is your friend.
late