Hello all! I have a problem that's been bothering/frustrating me for a while now, I've done a lot of research and done a lot of things but they all didn't work, please help me troubleshoot, thank you very much for your help! And excuse my English.
Purpose of Port Forwarding
I'm not doing anything crazy, I'm playing the game Rainbow Six Siege on a PC and I have a moderate instead of an open type NAT. This is frustrating as i can't host a game.
What I have done
I've researched a lot, and there are many solutions out there, but they are mainly all about port forwarding, and this is what I need help with. Note that I have UPNP turned on, so that's one less thing to worry about.
Administrator
192.168.1.161
Destination Ports 13000
TCP 13000 -> 13000
Active
Administrator
192.168.1.161
Destination Ports 13005
TCP 13005 -> 13005
Active
Administrator
192.168.1.161
Destination Ports 13200
TCP 13200 -> 13200
Active
Administrator
192.168.1.161
Destination Ports 14000
TCP 14000 -> 14000
Active
Administrator
192.168.1.161
Destination Ports 14001
TCP 14001 -> 14001
Active
Administrator
192.168.1.161
Destination Ports 14008
TCP 14008 -> 14008
Active
Administrator
192.168.1.161
Destination Ports 10000-10099
UDP 10000 - 10099 -> 10000 - 10099
Active
Administrator
192.168.1.161
Destination Ports 3074
TCP 3074 -> 3074
UDP 3074 -> 3074
Active
Administrator
192.168.1.161
Destination Ports 49152-65535
UDP 49152 - 65535 -> 49152 - 65535
Active
Administrator
192.168.1.161
Destination Ports 6015
UDP 6015 -> 6015
Active
(Sorry for the long list, but I want to give provide as much info as possible for better trouble shoot)
Note that although some suggested to open port 80 and 443, I did not do it because I heard it's a big security issue. However I tried to open port 80 and it did make my NAT to open, I don't want to keep it open though, and that's not the problem I'm describing for this thread.
Ports Won't Open
I downloaded the PFPortChecker from portforward.com to see if my ports are really opened, and this is where my problem begins, they are still CLOSED! For example, if I check port TCP 14000, it says "Your port is not open or not reachable"
Trying to troubleshoot
I tried to turn on DMZ, and it did in fact turn my NAT into open, and when I test my port, it's OPENED!.
However, I was just troubleshooting and I don't want to leave my PC exposed. I'm not sure what this implies, i guess it means that my computer is not broken, and it's just something is still preventing my ports to be opened when the DMZ is closed (since DMZ grants total exposure).
So, I completely shut down my Anti-virus software along with its firewall, also my windows 10 fire walls (for both private and public networks), I also went to my router's firewall setting, and selected the lowest possible setting for IPV4 (IPV6 is disabled BTW). This did not work, my 14000 port is closed this time.
Confused
At this point I'm pretty sure the reason I'm still getting a moderate NAT is because my ports are still closed somehow. Some may say that for a port to be forwarded successfully it needs set up on both sides, i don't think that's the problem in my case, since I'm testing with a dedicated port testing program, and it worked when DMZ was enabled. Also turning off all firewalls did not make the port open, so at this point I'm not sure what to do.
Thank you
Thank you for reading such a long thread, and I hope I explained the scenario enough, if not please let me know, and thank you very much for your time for helping me troubleshoot.
Some more Info / edits
- I have verizon FIOS, tried both direct wired and wifi adapter, neither worked
- I tried to turn on "find on network" function in the network setting, did not help
- Like many online sources suggested, I set my IP to static and it didn't help
Purpose of Port Forwarding
I'm not doing anything crazy, I'm playing the game Rainbow Six Siege on a PC and I have a moderate instead of an open type NAT. This is frustrating as i can't host a game.
What I have done
I've researched a lot, and there are many solutions out there, but they are mainly all about port forwarding, and this is what I need help with. Note that I have UPNP turned on, so that's one less thing to worry about.
Administrator
192.168.1.161
Destination Ports 13000
TCP 13000 -> 13000
Active
Administrator
192.168.1.161
Destination Ports 13005
TCP 13005 -> 13005
Active
Administrator
192.168.1.161
Destination Ports 13200
TCP 13200 -> 13200
Active
Administrator
192.168.1.161
Destination Ports 14000
TCP 14000 -> 14000
Active
Administrator
192.168.1.161
Destination Ports 14001
TCP 14001 -> 14001
Active
Administrator
192.168.1.161
Destination Ports 14008
TCP 14008 -> 14008
Active
Administrator
192.168.1.161
Destination Ports 10000-10099
UDP 10000 - 10099 -> 10000 - 10099
Active
Administrator
192.168.1.161
Destination Ports 3074
TCP 3074 -> 3074
UDP 3074 -> 3074
Active
Administrator
192.168.1.161
Destination Ports 49152-65535
UDP 49152 - 65535 -> 49152 - 65535
Active
Administrator
192.168.1.161
Destination Ports 6015
UDP 6015 -> 6015
Active
(Sorry for the long list, but I want to give provide as much info as possible for better trouble shoot)
Note that although some suggested to open port 80 and 443, I did not do it because I heard it's a big security issue. However I tried to open port 80 and it did make my NAT to open, I don't want to keep it open though, and that's not the problem I'm describing for this thread.
Ports Won't Open
I downloaded the PFPortChecker from portforward.com to see if my ports are really opened, and this is where my problem begins, they are still CLOSED! For example, if I check port TCP 14000, it says "Your port is not open or not reachable"
Trying to troubleshoot
I tried to turn on DMZ, and it did in fact turn my NAT into open, and when I test my port, it's OPENED!.
However, I was just troubleshooting and I don't want to leave my PC exposed. I'm not sure what this implies, i guess it means that my computer is not broken, and it's just something is still preventing my ports to be opened when the DMZ is closed (since DMZ grants total exposure).
So, I completely shut down my Anti-virus software along with its firewall, also my windows 10 fire walls (for both private and public networks), I also went to my router's firewall setting, and selected the lowest possible setting for IPV4 (IPV6 is disabled BTW). This did not work, my 14000 port is closed this time.
Confused
At this point I'm pretty sure the reason I'm still getting a moderate NAT is because my ports are still closed somehow. Some may say that for a port to be forwarded successfully it needs set up on both sides, i don't think that's the problem in my case, since I'm testing with a dedicated port testing program, and it worked when DMZ was enabled. Also turning off all firewalls did not make the port open, so at this point I'm not sure what to do.
Thank you
Thank you for reading such a long thread, and I hope I explained the scenario enough, if not please let me know, and thank you very much for your time for helping me troubleshoot.
Some more Info / edits
- I have verizon FIOS, tried both direct wired and wifi adapter, neither worked
- I tried to turn on "find on network" function in the network setting, did not help
- Like many online sources suggested, I set my IP to static and it didn't help