[SOLVED] Rx 570 8gb or Rx 580 8gb?

[3bec]

Hello. So im just asking my self what is better because im considering to buy one of these but i dont know what to choose. The RX 580 is from XFX company and the RX 570 is from MSI. (Both of them are 8gb versions). I dont know much about the XFX company but i read that they dont make good coolings for the cards. So im little bit scared about this because i want to over clock my card and i dont want the card to run at high temperatures and die after 2 months you know.

 

[Phaaze88]

Make and model of the power supply?

 

[geofelt]

Those cards were extensively used for mining.
If you are buying used, I would buy something else.
Also, they are power hungry, needing 500-550w power supplies.
I would look to a comparable performing modern card like a GTX1660.

 

[3bec]

Those cards were extensively used for mining.
If you are buying used, I would buy something else.
Also, they are power hungry, needing 500-550w power supplies.
I would look to a comparable performing modern card like a GTX1660.

How can it be used for mining if im buying a new one? 😀

 

[tennis2]

I RX580.

What's the price of each? Country?

 

[cryoburner]

So im little bit scared about this because i want to over clock my card and i dont want the card to run at high temperatures and die after 2 months you know.

An overclocked RX570 will never match the performance of an RX 580. An RX 580 should be nearly 15% faster than an RX 570 in graphics-limited scenarios, whereas overclocking a graphics card will typically not give you more than a few percent more performance. It's probably not worth bothering to overclocking these cards, as the difference in performance is unlikely to be noticeable compared to stock, but temperatures and power draw will be higher.

Of course, RX 570s tend to cost less, which might be worth considering. I wouldn't pay a similar amount for an RX 570 compared to an RX 580.

If buying new, you might also consider something like the newer GTX 1650 SUPER, as that card is often slightly faster than an RX 580. It only has 4GB of VRAM though, so it might not hold up quite as well in the future. A GTX 1660 could be a good option too though, as it can be over 15% faster than either of those cards, and has a decent 6GB of VRAM.

 

[3bec]

I RX580.

What's the price of each? Country?

Im living in Slovakia. So rx 580 8gb is like 190€ Sapphire version and rx 570 8gb is like 160€

 

[3bec]

An overclocked RX570 will never match the performance of an RX 580. An RX 580 should be nearly 15% faster than an RX 570 in graphics-limited scenarios, whereas overclocking a graphics card will typically not give you more than a few percent more performance. It's probably not worth bothering to overclocking these cards, as the difference in performance is unlikely to be noticeable compared to stock, but temperatures and power draw will be higher.

Of course, RX 570s tend to cost less, which might be worth considering. I wouldn't pay a similar amount for an RX 570 compared to an RX 580.

If buying new, you might also consider something like the newer GTX 1650 SUPER, as that card is often slightly faster than an RX 580. It only has 4GB of VRAM though, so it might not hold up quite as well in the future. A GTX 1660 could be a good option too though, as it can be over 15% faster than either of those cards, and has a decent 6GB of VRAM.

Ok so yes the 1650S is better but its like 200€ in slovakia and rx 580 is like 180-190€ you know and it has more memory than the 1650S

And also, i want to over clock the rx 580 8gb not the rx 570 8gb.

 

[Phaaze88]

I read about the rx 580 8gb and Gtx 1650 and the 1650 is slower than the rx 580 8gb. https://gpu.userbenchmark.com/Compare/Nvidia-GTX-1650-vs-AMD-RX-580/4039vs3923

Wrong gpu. The gpu that was suggested was the 1650 SUPER.

And also, i want to over clock the rx 580 8gb not the rx 570 8gb.

And this is why I asked earlier what the make and model of your psu was. If you cheaped out here, just forget about an RX 580. It does not play nice with low quality units.
The 1650 Super isn't as power hungry, and is less likely to whine when paired with such a psu.

 

[3bec]

Wrong gpu. The gpu that was suggested was the 1650 SUPER.


And this is why I asked earlier what the make and model of your psu was. If you cheaped out here, just forget about an RX 580. It does not play nice with low quality units.
The 1650 Super isn't as power hungry, and is less likely to whine when paired with such a psu.

Thanks for the reply. I know, i fast edited it but you replyed to it even faster. 😀 Ok so guys you changed my mind so im buying 1650S. And one more question. Will it work well with the i3-9100f? Right now im going to check whats the bottleneck.

 

[3bec]

Thanks for the reply. I know, i fast edited it but you replyed to it even faster. 😀 Ok so guys you changed my mind so im buying 1650S. And one more question. Will it work well with the i3-9100f? Right now im going to check whats the bottleneck.

Oh and also PSU is Fortron SP500-A, 450W, 500W

 

[WildCard999]

How can it be used for mining if im buying a new one? 😀

A few companies made GPU's just for mining.

 

[tennis2]

Im living in Slovakia. So rx 580 8gb is like 190€ Sapphire version and rx 570 8gb is like 160€

That's roughly in line with the % performance difference between the two.

 

[vov4ik_il]

Hello. So im just asking my self what is better because im considering to buy one of these but i dont know what to choose. The RX 580 is from XFX company and the RX 570 is from MSI. (Both of them are 8gb versions). I dont know much about the XFX company but i read that they dont make good coolings for the cards. So im little bit scared about this because i want to over clock my card and i dont want the card to run at high temperatures and die after 2 months you know.

I have XFX RX580. It is as good as a 1060 for the most part, but consumes more power.
The best overclocking, is sparing a dime for the next faster card.

 

[Phaaze88]

Fortron SP500-A

Yeah, forget the RX 580.