G
Guest
Guest
Archived from groups: rec.video.desktop,rec.video.production,rec.arts.movies.production.sound (More info?)
"Jan Panteltje" <pNaonStpealmtje@yahoo.com> wrote in message
news:1109196242.1687a51bc44b20524ddcbe0c618ecb70@teranews...
> On a sunny day (Wed, 23 Feb 2005 21:19:07 GMT) it happened "nap"
> <gospam@yourself.com> wrote in
> <fr6Td.8717$Pz7.8474@newssvr13.news.prodigy.com>:
>
>>
>>Exactly what are you talking about? I am an engineer. I have written code
>>for MP3 systems, about to work on another, and I can tell you that NO
>>ONE'S
>>ears can differentiate the finer points of MP3 compression. Anyone who
>>thinks they can use their ears to 'review' a product is.... a joker.
> Hehe, I am electronics enineer with > 35 years experience, many of it in
> broacasting, many of it in design.
> I have been reading all this, and listen test can reveal a lot (to trained
> people especially).
> Already in the sixties I learned to listen to the sound people in the
> studio.
> You can learn.
> In fact I would not have lasted a week if I had not!
> It is team work.
> So, what mp3 system did you design? What about psychoacoustic models? I
> can
> hear differences there myself, and WTF is a 'finer point', please be
> specific.
> At least respect the profesional experience of others.
I started mixing records in the 70's Worked in most major West Coast
Studios. And with 30 years engineering I can tell you that the idea that
'trained' people can discern the differences in high bandwidth mp3 is
ludicrous. I'd be interested in what exactly constitues a "trained" ear.
"Jan Panteltje" <pNaonStpealmtje@yahoo.com> wrote in message
news:1109196242.1687a51bc44b20524ddcbe0c618ecb70@teranews...
> On a sunny day (Wed, 23 Feb 2005 21:19:07 GMT) it happened "nap"
> <gospam@yourself.com> wrote in
> <fr6Td.8717$Pz7.8474@newssvr13.news.prodigy.com>:
>
>>
>>Exactly what are you talking about? I am an engineer. I have written code
>>for MP3 systems, about to work on another, and I can tell you that NO
>>ONE'S
>>ears can differentiate the finer points of MP3 compression. Anyone who
>>thinks they can use their ears to 'review' a product is.... a joker.
> Hehe, I am electronics enineer with > 35 years experience, many of it in
> broacasting, many of it in design.
> I have been reading all this, and listen test can reveal a lot (to trained
> people especially).
> Already in the sixties I learned to listen to the sound people in the
> studio.
> You can learn.
> In fact I would not have lasted a week if I had not!
> It is team work.
> So, what mp3 system did you design? What about psychoacoustic models? I
> can
> hear differences there myself, and WTF is a 'finer point', please be
> specific.
> At least respect the profesional experience of others.
I started mixing records in the 70's Worked in most major West Coast
Studios. And with 30 years engineering I can tell you that the idea that
'trained' people can discern the differences in high bandwidth mp3 is
ludicrous. I'd be interested in what exactly constitues a "trained" ear.