MrsKing,
The lost printer used ink cartridge 126.
The similar replacement printer you found on Amazon uses ink cartridge 220.
You will probably not be able to use the 126 cartridge(s). The possible exception being something like my Canon MX870 that uses two different black ink cartridges; one large, one small - different ink cartridge number. Both cartridges are installed in their own slot.
By the way, you may be able to go into your computer device manager and look at the printer drivers etc. to identify the Epson model number or something else to help specify the lost printer's model number. Or look at Epson's website and see if you can visually identify the all-in-one.
May find a more definitive answer to the ink cartridge...