Assuming you are not yet on GTX980Ti,
Here is the deal, run the games, which you think than your processor has already bottlenecking. During the game, try to control the processor load and the GPU load, assuming you have enough RAM.
If only the GPU runs 100% all the time but the game still runs on low fps, you need only the new GPU.
If only the processor runs 100% all the time but the game still runs on low fps, you need only the new processor.
If both the processor and GPU runs 100% all the time but the game still runs on low fps, you need a fully new rig.
assuming you are already on GTX980Ti.
If you see low fps on 1080p or 1440p, just replace the proc without further thinking.