Valve Boss: EA Origin Isn't ''Doing Anything Super-Well Yet''

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the Tom's Hardware community: where nearly two million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Valve Boss: EA Origin Isn't ''Doing Anything Super-Well Yet''

I disagree with this.


They do something Super-Well.....pissing the gamers off.
 
Valve Boss: EA Origin Isn't ''Doing Anything Super-Well Yet''

I disagree with this.


They do something Super-Well.....pissing the gamers off.
 
[citation][nom]casualcolors[/nom]Perhaps if you had a clearer understanding of history as recent as within the last 12 months, you'd be familiar with the reason why EA pulled their games from the Steam service in the first place. Their products that weren't originally part and parcel to the Origin service were rolled into it to essentially fill the role of the old EA downloader, which is presently defunct. The games were pulled from Steam because Valve attempted to assert a DLC policy concerning Battlefield 3 in particular that was disagreeable to EA and bordered on harmful to other retailers that EA supplies both retail game copies as well as DLC to. Regardless of how you want to look at EA, both they and Valve are eminently shrewd and you shouldn't be misled into thinking there is any good guy or bad guy when it comes to corporate relations in the world. That's an entirely too simple light to view things in.[/citation]

ea wanted dlc to be in game only, cutting out valve
valve wants dlc out of the game, which i believe it should be too.

i dont want in game dlc as much as i dont want in app purchase...
ea got way to greedy, and cut ties with steam.

[citation][nom]rantoc[/nom]Orgin downloads are always at 9-10mb/sec, Steam downloads about 1-2mb/sec. I hope Valve turn up the steam, the service is closer to still water than steam as of late - At least in Northern Europe. Both are download services and download speed is in my book one of the biggest values as a customer.[/citation]

i like not haveing my computer scanned, i also like steam. downloads are a 1 time deal for me, so speed isnt a huge factor, so long as its at least 1mbps im ok.

[citation][nom]mrpijey[/nom]Oh I understand it just fine thank you. My main issue isn't with Origin itself (even if I hate that I need to have yet another leaky service with my personal info just to play a game) but with EA that is by now well known for its hatred towards paying customers.And one very good point made in this thread is that Steam covers a lot of publishers. Origin covers EA, period. So when will we have BethesdaStore? ID-Wallet? MojangShop? ActivisionDollarSqueezer? Every publisher makes their own little store, just to pump customers of more personal info, draconian copy protections and buggy inbetween-software to slow down and cripple our computers... Steam was first and it has developed to a well respected and well used service. And one would think that companies would try to use the most known and most populated services to promote their software, not to make small stores of their own carrying a handful of games instead of thousands like Steam.And I also know very well the corporate world is everything but a dance on roses but here I choose the lesser of two evils - Valve. Valve has quality products behind them, a well established customer support and they listen to their fans. EA has gone from a respected developer to a black hole where there is no escape from - once EA sets their sight on a good developer they get sucked in and forced to make crappy console rehashes and endless sequels, each worse than the previous. I can't remember when the last time I was really excited over an EA game. Valve has continued to suprise me with excellent titles that stand up to time even today. Half-Life series. Portal series. Team Fortress 2. Heck, even Counter-Strike which I refuse to touch, but I can still see the quality behind it. With EA it's been endless crap products that may have looked nice at the surface, but quickly fell apart as soon as you touched it. And these endless sequels... The Sims series being the most notorious ones. The utter crappy Need For Speed series they dragged through the mud. And now Battlefield going the same way. There is just no end to their hunger of swallowing up creative studios and remaking them into drones, forking out one bad sequel after another.There was once a time I pulled a smile everytime I heard "EA Games - It's In the Game!". Today it's more "Oh crap, I hope this isn't one more cheesy console port sequel...". And yes, I am old enough to have experienced Skate Or Die! which was their first game. i still have the original floppy.Sorry for the long post, but I just don't have much respect for EA anymore after their swallowed up and killed most of my favorite developer studios - Bullfrog, Interplay, Binary Systems, Origin Systems (Wing Commander ), Maxis, Digital Illusions (for whom I worked for). And now I have to use their shoddy software just to play an occasional game from them (which is Mass Effect 3, and soon Crysis 3). Phooey.EA, give Valve a nice present, kiss and make up and strike some kind of deal. For the good of the customers.[/citation]

you missed westwood, than they fired almost all the staff... thats the one that stuck out the most for me...
maxis, i dont believe was touched, its just that will write went insane, and developed pet projects that were ok at first, but sucked more and more as the years went on.

[citation][nom]catatafish[/nom]I couldn't care less about any of this except for one thing......pardoning banned players. Banned means banned, not grounded. This just tells me that there are A LOT of banned players for them to forgive them and get them back as paying customers. If Pete Rose can't return to baseball, then I_Use_Aimbot_to_Dart_Spam shouldn't get to return to BF3.[/citation]

banned on the forums, means banned in an ea game.
complain about the game, banned
want to talk about the game... you are on thin ice
an obvious glitch gets pointed out... ban

i dont believe they ever fixed this, or at least it was never mentioned.
one person who got banned from playing ANY game of theirs from ea, didnt even do anything bad, someone else did, and quoted the guy, and he was banned.

ea has a SEVER ban problem with their service.

 
I agree with Gabe completely here. Origin does not add value at all. It is just as clumsy and buggy as EA Downloader, EA Link, and all of EA's previous attempts at a Steam competitor. Origin is poorly managed, abusive to gamers, horribly supported, and doesn't fit into a cohesive ecosystem like Steam does.

I really like Steam because it makes it so easy to chat with friends, find out what games they have, and them seamlessly join their games even if they're already in progress. The friends tools make it easy to invite more friends or randomly drop in on people too. It's a killer feature. What does Origin have for comparison? Well it has its own friends list and its own chat system. You can't actually use that to join friends' games. EA wants you to chat through Origin and also chat through battlelog or autolog or whatever Facebook-type social site they want to set up. You have to log into multiple places in order to start playing a game. Be careful if you try to use the Origin-overlay when in game too. It likes to crash the game or reduce performance dramatically! Let's also not forget the ads that sometimes pop up during a game and cause it to minimize. Origin also likes to go down a lot making Origin games unplayable. I also can't count the number of times I've seen "Disconnected from EA Online (1)" in BF3. Absolutely ridiculous.

There is no excuse for EA not doing things "super well" or having to play catch-up to Steam. Steam has been around for many years. It's not new. It has been refined and improved over the years. It is the baseline for any competing service going forward. Origin doesn't even come close to that baseline. Impulse, or whatever Gamestop turned it into, is a much better solution than Origin. Impulse doesn't get in my way, manages to update my games quickly, runs sales, and sells products from a whole host of developers and publishers. It's lacking that killer friends feature list, but at least it doesn't actively get in my way like Origin does.

I have a positive opinion of Steam and Impulse and a highly negative opinion over Origin from an incident in January of this year were I my EA account got banned an entire week for a ridiculous parade of excuses. It's a bug, now it's some sort of misconduct ban, oh it's an entitlement bug, maybe the studio banned you, did you post criticism on the forums, or come back tomorrow and it'll be fixed were all ridiculous explanations. Origin help would just throw discount codes and free games at me -- none in which I accepted or used even after the ban lifted. I've never had a problem even remotely similar in all my years using Steam or Impulse.

So again, I agree completely with Gabe. I like Steam. Valve seems to get it. Origin was the shove I needed to get me to stop giving EA chances to redeem themselves.
 
[citation][nom]thrakazog[/nom]I'm not sure why there's so much hooha over origin. I use both steam and origin, and have never had problems with them. I've seen a couple new releases from EA appear on both origin and steam. Warp was one, don't remember the other. As far as I'm concerned, they are just a couple stores to buy stuff at. Whichever has the best price price, I get it there. For instance, been watching steam for a long time looking for a sale on street fighter 4 AE. But it's always been $39.99, never cheaper. When origin had it for $10, I grabbed it. I agree, for the most part, they don't have a lot of stuff for sale yet on origin. But they are still growing.I'll use them to buy stuff whenever it's cheap or something I want, the same as I do on steam.[/citation]

That would make sense, except that they never increased the price of a title that they pulled from Steam. You're literally fabricating both a motive and reality which is a good indication that you have essentially no idea what you're talking about.
 
[citation][nom]DroKing[/nom]EA's full of it. They pulled them all off steam because they wanna jack prices up period. I already compared prices steam n origin on website and I seen some games being 30 buck more expensive on origin over steam. EA actions are very obvious no discussion.[/citation]

That would make sense, except that they never increased the price of a title that they pulled from Steam. You're literally fabricating both a motive and reality which is a good indication that you have essentially no idea what you're talking about.
 
[citation][nom]alidan[/nom] i like not haveing my computer scanned.[/citation]

Personally I'm less concerned about having my install-drive scanned for compatible games (which is what Origin does), and more concerned that Steam has had two significant security breaches in the course of two years and never actually owned up to what was hacked and what information was compromised. All Valve ever offered was the general opinion that my credit card was "probably" not compromised, along with the rest of their report to customers being worded in similarly vague terms. Sadly that is because they have no idea what happened and would have gone out of their way not to mention it at all if it hadn't been ready to leak everywhere on the internet anyway.

If you fanboy for EA or Valve, you're determined to be as foolish and remain as ignorant as humanly possible. EA is as much a group of alter boys as Valve is a magnanimous publishing entity, which is to say neither fit those descriptions at all.

 
[citation][nom]frostyfireball[/nom]EA's loss, I won't be buying EA games if I have to do it through Origin. ME3 will be the exception, but after that I'm done with them until Origin dies.[/citation]
The sad part is we all have that one exception. They got us by the cajones.
 
[citation][nom]casualcolors[/nom]That would make sense, except that they never increased the price of a title that they pulled from Steam. You're literally fabricating both a motive and reality which is a good indication that you have essentially no idea what you're talking about.[/citation]

LOL right.... I smell EA bribe. EA is the worst company period next to Activihack and Ubisoft.
 
I have both Steam and Origin. Origin makes my blood boil, I don't like having to sign in to two programs. Origin feels half-assed. Can't stand the web browser nonsense. Steam is great and well polished. Woulda been nice to have bf3 on steam too. When im done laying bf3 ill be done with origin.
 
It's funny that no one mentions how Valve´s games are exclusive to Steam. So, how come you can be so hypocritical about the whole thing, it is ok for Valve to ONLY publish it's games on Steam and never consider any other services, but if EA does it, it suddenly becomes something to keep the blame and finger-pointing game running? I think not
 
[citation][nom]Tab54o[/nom]I have both Steam and Origin. Origin makes my blood boil, I don't like having to sign in to two programs. Origin feels half-assed. Can't stand the web browser nonsense. Steam is great and well polished. Woulda been nice to have bf3 on steam too. When im done laying bf3 ill be done with origin.[/citation]

It's called facts, something you seem to be lacking of
 
[citation][nom]DroKing[/nom]EA's full of it. They pulled them all off steam because they wanna jack prices up period. I already compared prices steam n origin on website and I seen some games being 30 buck more expensive on origin over steam. EA actions are very obvious no discussion.[/citation]

If only that was true (which is not) please, why don't you get your facts right before posting? Ow right, this is the internets, i totally forgot that
 
[citation][nom]Middleman[/nom]So, how's Episode 3 coming along Gabe? No answer? Yeah, that's what I thought. Sit down and shut up.[/citation]

http://www.ubergizmo.com/2012/04/half-life-3-rumoredly-masquerading-as-ricochet-2/
 
I bought ME3 on DVD. When I went to install it, origin proceeded to download and install the game instead of letting me install from the DVD. With steam, I buy a game on DVD, install it, it will register with steam and download updates, but doesnt make me download the whole thing to install... If it wasnt for ME3 I wouldnt bother with origin.... 🙁
 
not shocked given the rummors of Nexon offering to buyout EA, I would be more shocked if that rummor was true about the buy out. anyone could tell you origin is not doing well just for the fact they charge sales tax, that alone makes me avoid it. no point getting digital if it's cheaper getting a hard copy or for the same price.

http://games.ign.com/articles/122/1223835p1.html?nxid=14

EA has really been going downhill over the years since they started buying out companys thru their old publishing programs or whatever it was that DICE and a few other companys had with them. eatting up companys like EA has done could put a strain on money if they don't do too well or cause problems.
 
[citation][nom]DroKing[/nom]LOL right.... I smell EA bribe. EA is the worst company period next to Activihack and Ubisoft.[/citation]

There is a way to use ad hominem in an argument, and that isn't it. You also can't refute the fact that Origin didn't result in any price hikes (given the conspicuous lack of a contrary example), and conversely it acts as a competitor to Steam in the same market-space, and is a potential catalyst for sales between Origin, Steam, Amazon, and Gamersgate. The only way I can see that being confusing is if you've never passed a basic economics course in high school.
 
[citation][nom]casualcolors[/nom]Personally I'm less concerned about having my install-drive scanned for compatible games (which is what Origin does), and more concerned that Steam has had two significant security breaches in the course of two years and never actually owned up to what was hacked and what information was compromised. All Valve ever offered was the general opinion that my credit card was "probably" not compromised, along with the rest of their report to customers being worded in similarly vague terms. Sadly that is because they have no idea what happened and would have gone out of their way not to mention it at all if it hadn't been ready to leak everywhere on the internet anyway.If you fanboy for EA or Valve, you're determined to be as foolish and remain as ignorant as humanly possible. EA is as much a group of alter boys as Valve is a magnanimous publishing entity, which is to say neither fit those descriptions at all.[/citation]

you have no idea how hard it is to verify infromation and what may or may not have been taken. from what i remember they were fast to tell us, and gave use the best answers they could.
 
However, it seems that EA’s been taking steps to turn Origin’s image around, recently introducing an update to Origin’s account policies that allow banned players to continue to access their games.

How is giving hackers a free pass to hack gonna turn there image around? I own BF3, but I "HATE" origin. Please EA, stop trying to force loyal Steam fans to install your junk software on our PC's..
 
[citation][nom]zachusaman[/nom]From what I understand, Steams game policy is this: If your game has DLC, it must be available to steam users. EA went out of their way and made some crysis 2 dlc exclusive to some other service, and Steam pulled the plug.(then Crysis 2 went ahead and won the most pirated game of the year award)[/citation]
It's not just DLCs, but also preorder rewards. BF3 for example had diff rewards for different retailers, some had extra dog tags, some had physical warfare pack, some had neither, Valve demands that they have them all. Also Problem is with updates, Valve is charging distribution of updates and demands that their servers be used for it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

TRENDING THREADS