Virtual Reality, a Solution For America's Obesity Problem?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the Tom's Hardware community: where nearly two million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Maybe they should put less crap in our food. Less processed crap. Less tax break-capturing chemicals. Less shelf life-extending ingredients. Nobody wants to touch the big businesses that create our food. Nobody wants to talk about ending incentives that help specific industries like the corn, wheat, and cattle industries. Hell, we even feed our livestock crap before turning them into steaks and bacon. I don't see the point in attacking the results of our problems when the root cause is obvious. Clearly the economy is just fine because we're still paying for bunk studies like this one.

Encouraging people to have skinny avatars doesn't make any sense to me. What does it say about me if my avatar in something like Second Life is fat and non-human? I'm of a normal, healthy weight, but my avatars tend to be large when there's no hitbox penalty. Is this researcher trying to claim that Pandas in WoW are making people fat? This study leads to all sorts of bizarre conclusions that ignore the root of our problems.
 
[citation][nom]killerclick[/nom]Also, lack of activity isn't the main cause of obesity. It's overeating, it's the food. The way fatties eat, they'd have to swim 6 hours a day like Michael Phelps to create a calorie deficit. And that would just make them more hungry, so it's a vicious cycle.[/citation]

You are spot on!
I have lived on junk food/pasta/milk and basic food my whole life am now in late 30's,I Don't eat much fruit,I Don't eat many vegetables at all and no meat yet I am not fat or skinny, Just normal.
I have been trying to tell people for ages that all this stuff out there is just bullshit, I don't have superior genetics far from it, It all comes down to how much you are putting in your mouth not what you are putting in your mouth. If you are putting in more calories than you burn off then you are going to get fat even if all you are eating is health food it wont matter. Try explaining it though they just don't get it or accept it. I mean seriously you think our ancestors gave a toss about how many calories was in that berry they just picked off the tree or how much protein/carbs/fat content is in that piece of venison from the deer they just hunted? Doubt it!
People OVER EAT and they also DON'T read the damn packet, Most of those ready made meals may look small but if you bother to read it, It says it SERVES 2 or more, not ONE. People are eating the entire meal which is meant to be 2 or more serves. Even a small frozen pizza from supermarket, Yes we can all easily eat the entire thing in one sitting but I am sure if they bother to read the label on the back it will say it serves 4. lol
 
yeah right, ugly fatasses have been hiding being the internet since it's inception, how else do sleezy old men pick up on pre-teen chicks! Or on the other hand divorced single mothers trolling for sugar dadies ...
 
LOL @ people saying fat people are unproductive. While I'm no 300 pounds, I do weight around 190. I would put money on it that I could out work all you "educated" idiots. Educated in quotes because half you people can't even spell correctly yet seem to know everything.

Fat doesn't automatically mean people are lazy. I've worked plenty of manual labor jobs, and was also in the military. I know plenty of "fat" people that are hard workers, take care of their family, and overall just good people. Yet they must be lazy, unproductive, worthless because they're fat?

People that say crap like that are usually the worthless ones that the world would be better off if they weren't around.
 
I think a start would be being able to talk about things like artificial sweeteners, preservatives, GMO, vaccines, etc. being possible problems without people instantly being labeled kook conspiracy theorists and kicked out of any discussions by mainstream establishment zealots.
 
[citation][nom]killerclick[/nom]Fatties are not unproductive,....[/citation]
He mentioned sick people, not fat people.

[citation][nom]brickman[/nom]Yes I want to look like my Dragonborn in Skyrim. Need those ripped abs and shouting at everyone[/citation]
I used to work out, but then I took an arrow in the knee...
 
I love how this news starts: Let's be honest, our views on how much food we should consume are completely out of control.

Well, i dont know about gouy guys, but i heard countless times that the best exercise is Sex. Yet for some damn reason, girls rather be on diet, eat very crappy food, go to gyms, and god knows what else.
Are we guys really so discusting?!
 
Personalized behavioral modification...because thoughts become action (or inaction). It is difficult though, because of the aforementioned consumerism. We need to start with quality before quantity. It all starts with energy. We grow regardless, so why not take it in a positive direction? The first gift of life IS growth. The second gift is mobility, so get up and move! The often forgotten third gift is control, or rather SELF-CONTROL, so use it.
 
[citation][nom]MrMez[/nom]It's a thyroid problem[/citation]
No, it's AD-36, the fat virus! It really exists. You catch it from places like Walmart, schools, and I'm sure gyms are slathering it all over their equipment to make sure you always come back. It's a trap!
 
I love how there is always some secret way to get in shape. Here's some news guys, don't be a fatass and you won't have a fat ass. Eat right and exercise, it's not that hard. If you really care about your body, then you'll do it. Also, I'm eating pumpkin pie whilst spending my time trolling the interwebs.
 
[citation][nom]lostmyclan[/nom]Iam Fat I have a died of 1500 Kcal per day. =) Still fat 110kg. I don´t walk too much. Never run. but I play some games. 6 hours per day.And Iam still fat. How much the people can eat doesnt matters. When aim im army loose about 1kg for week. Eating like a pig more than 3000 Kcal per day.Exercise make you slim. Sitting all day make you fat. Doesnt matter if your pic is fat our slim[/citation]

Wrong.

I lost weight doing -0- exercise. I lost 75 pounds so far, all I do is go to my College/study and play games. I eat smaller meals, keep it around 1500 cals a day.

The calorie number depends on what your body burns by doing nothing. If your body burns 1800 calories a day with you doing nothing, then eating 1500 will probably do nothing to make you lose weight. But if your body burns 3000 doing nothing to stay alive, then yea you'll lose weight.


 
[citation][nom]weierstrass[/nom]How about a weight tax?[/citation]
tax us when evolution kicks in, at least than you have no reason to be fat.
we are fat now because most jobs no longer require us to move around for hours apon hours a day, and most of those jobs are minimum wage or barely more than minimum and un desireable.

whether we move around all day, or we sit down all day to work doesn't matter, our bodies want food.
for me to be satisfied with a meal, its about 1000-1500 calories worth of food, even when the food is healthy. if i eat less than that, im constantly hungry, but god knows i probably don't need more than 1000 calories a day to sustain my current life style. and what is this, running 1 mile nets you want 50 caleries... yea, i could exaust my self running all damn day but it wouldn't even make a dent and i will not work over 8 hours a day, than spend the rest of my day working out just so im not taxed.

point being wait till we evolve to where out current life styles are compensated by our meals, in 1-200 years i would say we will ajust completely for technology not requiring us to move as much.

[citation][nom]chairman ray[/nom]While I agree that a high-degree of self presence in virtual worlds may lead to motivation for weight loss, attaining this high-degree of self presence requires one to invest a significant portion of time on these online activities, which is one of the leading causes of obesity in the first place.The most obvious discredit towards this research is that in every game, the characters you play as or design are already meant to be attractive and it has never, ever curbed obesity. These characters serve to get the player to play more, rather than less. If attractive characters encouraged people to get off the computer and go outside, developers would be making ugly characters instead.[/citation]

get us a game where we move around.
if a game with 1 to 1 sword combat ever really came out, and required me to move, i would be in shape just because i love that style of game.

[citation][nom]killerclick[/nom]How about you let fatties be fat? Sure, they cost more in healthcare but they die sooner, they create revenue for businesses that sell food and they make the rest of us look better in comparison.[/citation]

how about people design health care around fat people? make an mri 2-3 times larger inside, and you wouldn't need a zoo to lend you theirs for a 400lb person.

also, define fat, because skinny people are usually less healthy than people who are on the edge between obese and in shape according to that retarded bmi system.

[citation][nom]killerclick[/nom]Also, lack of activity isn't the main cause of obesity. It's overeating, it's the food. The way fatties eat, they'd have to swim 6 hours a day like Michael Phelps to create a calorie deficit. And that would just make them more hungry, so it's a vicious cycle.[/citation]

i would rather be dead than hungry, and as i said, a filling meal for me is 1000-1500 calories of food that is healthy, much more when its not healthy food. [citation][nom]joytech22[/nom]What they SHOULD do is create a VR headset and body suit and create a game similar to GMOD (Or use GMOD). Then through this suit the user should be able to play around with spawned objects like bouncy balls and play sports through the game.They not only would have fun in this virtual world, but they could also do some real working out (As in, they could run around) and they'd be able to have fun while doing it.Although.. I'm not sure how it would be more fun than doing the real thing unless they are playing over the net or something.[/citation]

you make that sword fighting game, and i will be fit enough for the olympics.

[citation][nom]the1kingbob[/nom]This is partly true. If people were not so fat, the nation as a whole wouldn't be spending so much money on food and health related problems to being fat. They would though, be spending money on activity based consumer products. This overlooks the drastic savings to businesses that provide healthcare coverage. We already see a shift, companies realize that it is economically beneficial to pay employees to work out to get long term savings and discounts from insurance companies.I agree with your second comment, diet is 80% of weight control. You can run for an hour on a treadmill, but it is going to help much if you eat a few donuts for breakfast. The problem is what we eat, but more importantly how much we eat.[/citation]
and that is why i gave up ever trying to get thin.
ever look at a work out diet?
ever get a work out program try it for a while, see no results only to find out that its not the work out its the diet and how small the portions are or how much i hate every single food they suggest i eat.

[citation][nom]memadmax[/nom]There is also the job aspect. Alot of american jobs are now barely active, from a physical aspect. You sit behind a desk or counter all day, hardly doing anything physical.[/citation]

and the jobs that are all active, are low paying and undesirable.

 
"279 users of Second Life"

That is hardly a good sample. How about testing 100,000 WoW players and see how many of them have an "attractive avatar" and use it to help visualize themselves as "thinner and healthier." Then go to the next step: Find out how many of them have actually gotten healthier after playing WoW for a few months. You will find the opposite is quite true.

How did this sad excuse for a study make the news? Sedentary activities like MMOs are part of the problem, not part of the solution.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.