If they're both DDR3, then get the cheapest, because DDR3 is also the system RAM, so it'll just take what it needs from it, IF it needs any more than the 2gbs, which it shouldn't unless it's a high end card.
If however one of them has DDR5, then no matter the quantity, VRAM speed makes a huge difference. Go right for the DDR5 even if it has less RAM.
Check Calculagator's link, it shows the difference between VRAM quantity and VRAM speed.