Windows 8 Will Remember Your Settings Across PCs

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the Tom's Hardware community: where nearly two million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Businesses have had this ability for over a decade, it's called a domain controller with roaming profiles.

Pretty useless for the home market if you ask me(creative use of a few free apps can give you this anyway, dropbox, etc.) and since it's already standard operating procedure for a business environment this hardly seems noteworthy.
 
I'm willing to bet that a lot of you that are complaining about Windows 8 now will be one of the first ones to buy it when it comes out. I didn't care for Windows 8 all that much when I first read about it but it's growing on me little by little. If they fix some of these issues and if it is true that there will be an option to disable metro UI then that will be a good thing, considering not everyone likes this Metro UI. If Windows 8 has better USB 3.0 support, better backup software, Better file transfer filing and uses less resoruces then Windows 7 then heck i'll give it a shot. I mean what's the worse that can happen not liking it and going back to Windows 7. I guess when the RC of Windows 8 comes out i'll make that judgement, but until then i'm willing to give Windows 8 a chance.
 
[citation][nom]jtt283[/nom]Businesses will NOT like this, unless they can create something on their secure domains that can do the same things for users on different PCs at work.[/citation]
Maybe they will. I work at a company that provides IT services to a bunch of business and technical schools in the area. We've already outsourced our students mail system to outlook.com and soon's we're able to implement it in a meaningful way, we'll probably move their storage system to skydrive as well.
There's no way we'd use this new settings system (in the way presented here) for the employees, but I happen to know we're looking at xencenter, vda and other terminal server like solutions we possibly could extend to handle more or less all employee related things. At least if vmware's solution is chosen I know we can even run autodesk and adobe products in such a manner.

Anyway, I see the potential of this system. As a techie I wouldn't much like it myself, but we've got some tablets running windows 8 and it seems to still have the explorer shell as well as the interface I'm used to from my phone (Windows Phone 7.5). So if we still have access to cmd with 1.2 extensions, powershell and explorer, I don't think it'll be a complete distaster like vista (out of 2300 systems in our sccm database, only 1 is vista).

We're currently using a mix of group policies, unc based menus and a website menu to control access to the right applications. With those shared settings, we could ditch those. Provided we have some sort of access to the user defaults that is.

In any event. I'm skeptical when it comes to power users, but I think it's a brilliant interface for grandma's and technical analphabets. And they're the majority of the windows user base. Anyone sitting with a mac now, will feel right at home with a new windows 8 system - except they'll be wondering why it doesn't feel slow of course.
 
The fact the Microsoft already has a copy of your Windows Live user ID and password makes the privacy issue a bit of a moot point.

[citation][nom]omenator[/nom]"Businesses will NOT like this, unless they can create something on their secure domains that can do the same things for users on different PCs at work." you mean like group policy and roaming user profiles?[/citation]

Do you know a lot of businesses that use Windows Live for signing into machines?

Optional feature is optional.
 
[citation][nom]alidan[/nom]explain how the start menu was broke? show us the new task managerpersonally i dont like the native mounting, as i see it as bloat. i am just hoping that win8 doesnt go the route of "if you dont use metro, well this and this wont work either..."[/citation]
The only thing the start menu was good for was 'run' and 'search', and it use to be good for sleep and shutdown before I got my new keyboard. Other things are easier to access with the quicklaunch/superbar, windows explorer, or to open a program by file association. Having things forced to be alphabetized makes it a little easier to find things on newer versions on windows, but it is still a disorganized mess where nothing can be found.
If you are new to windows, or have terrible file management, then the Start menu is a great way to get use to finding things, and get beginners to use a computer without understanding what they are doing. For those of us who control our computer instead of just use it, the start menu is just useless. But it is still a very necessary part of Windows for 80% of the people who use it, so I don't complain about it just because I don't use it.

MetroUI is not much better, but I am excited to see that they are at least trying to change something, and try something new. And no, it did not take away from my desktop experience. Switching between the 2 has (so far) been a smooth and seamless experience. Sure improvements need to be made, but as it is now just a proof of concept, and not a final product, I would expect nothing less.

The new task manager basically combines the old task manager with the old resource monitor. You now not only see how much CPU a program is taking, but also memory usage, idle/active state, network bandwidth, and HDD bandwidth. With more details you can see a breakdown of not only programs, but also Windows services and their usage. You can also change your startup items directly from task manager which is handy. With all of this new detail on what exactly is going on with the computer it will be very easy to trouble shoot problem programs, or at least rule out potential problems that were guesswork before.

As for native mounting; Some of us have big HDDs and put all of our program CDs on it so we don't have to deal with the evils and annoyances of optical media any longer (with rare exception anyways). It is much easier to find an image than to go through spindles and binders, and 'free range' discs that are stroon about the basement. For years we have had to use 3rd party mounters (which have much improved over the years), but now we just load Windows, and it is all ready for me.

Again, I dont want people to get me wrong. I will likely skip win8 as I don't feel I have gotten my money's worth out of win7 yet, and I believe win9 will have a much more mature metroUI. I have just been annoyed at people knocking win8 when they obviously have not used it (or at least did not give it a fair shake). The dev build is pretty fun to use (if a bit buggy). Many of you have a spare HDD laying around. Go install it and try the new features then come back and give some constructive criticism. What exactly is wrong with metroUI? It is the ugly green? Is it the fact that you can get quick look information without having to open anything? Is it that you fear it 'wastes too many resources' when in actuality the 64bit version runs just fine on a netbook with 1GB of RAM? Sure, metroUI is not something I particularly like, but it does not get in the way and there is potential there, so why complain?
 
[citation][nom]dragonsqrrl[/nom]MS has stated publicly that the Metro UI will be optional in the final release (you can disable it entirely).[/citation]
Please provide a link, and also did they mention if disabling the metro UI will take away further additions to the OS. For example, you can "disable" the Metro UI with the dev build, but it removes all the extra features of Task Manager.
 
so basically your telling me that Windows 8 will have a 'hole' in it...
I can see the amount of Windows Updates coming out just for this one feature alone...
still too early for Windows 8 with 7 so fresh and now becoming number 1 in OS's. I guess the mobile / tablet movement is growing even stronger..
 
It reminds me of the already very useful sync feature in Google Chrome. All that does is sync your bookmarks and addons, which is very helpful when you work in a place where you can potentially be on several different systems on any given day. It'd be nice to do the same with windows settings.
 
In all these months of frequent Microsoft videos about Windows 8 I still haven't seen the Metro UI functioning with a mouse and keyboard! I mean come on, their biggest market is the Desktop and Laptops not the freaking tablets! So why keep showing these videos using touch functionality? The vast majority of users won't have touch-capable LCD screens.
 
[citation][nom]joe gamer[/nom]Businesses have had this ability for over a decade, it's called a domain controller with roaming profiles. Pretty useless for the home market if you ask me(creative use of a few free apps can give you this anyway, dropbox, etc.) and since it's already standard operating procedure for a business environment this hardly seems noteworthy.[/citation]

Here we go again with the haters. Look, I dont wan't want a flippin domain controller and all the hassles at home. If the cloud is good enough which it seems then this equivalent to roaming profiles is a god send.

A home with various PC's, laptops, etc.. could definitely benefit from this when family members move around from their laptops to their PC's then back to their Windows 8 pads. Business users are not the only thing they are looking at to sell to.

On a side note the Metro UI is very functional and yes different. Just like the old DOS days to the MAC and Windows GUI change over. It may not be for us who are stuck doing things the "Old Way' but newer users will learn and find more efficient uses of these newer UI's including Metro. And for the last time; The Metro UI will be optional. Who knows if this is the start of custom GUI's for a Win platform.

My 25 cents.

FYI WP7 is a wonderful product especially with Zune services. :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.