Aperture Grill v. Shadow Mask

Red_Zealot

Distinguished
Feb 2, 2001
522
0
18,980
I am building a game-intensive LAN party system. I would like to know whwther an Aperture Grill or Shadow Mask monitor will provide better display of high quality graphics. The specific monitors I am considering are the CTX PR960F (aperture) and the Samsung SyncMaster 900IFT (shadow). Any feedback will be very much appreciated.

Abe
Intel = "I caNT bELieve you."
 
On brand issue the Samsung is better!
But the CTX monitor system is better for graphics!

Why don´t you consider a Sony G-400 (The best 19" monitor!)?
It´s better than the Samsung and has the Aperture grill System!

Better burn in Hell with some company than freeze in Heaven all alone
 
There was a little while there (late '99, early 2000) where Shadow mask monitors appeared to have gained the advantage over Apature grile. It seems to have gone back to where it's been for years where apature griles are better, but not as much as they once were.
 
Sorry, but the Compaq MV940 is the nicest 19" monitor. It has the most crisp picture I have ever seen. Not to mention that the monitor itself is beautiful, and it has the depth of a 17" monitor!

- I don't write Tom's Hardware Guide, I just preach it"
 
Damn, you´re starting to bug me!
4 posts with the same message!?

"Sorry, but the Compaq MV940 is the nicest 19" monitor. It has the most crisp picture I have ever seen"
No way, Sorry yourself!
You haven´t looked at the picture a Sony monitor has!
You just burned 500 squid on some piece of crap!

Better burn in Hell with some company than freeze in Heaven all alone
 
if money is no object, go for lacie electon 22 blue, the sweetest under 24 inch monitor around
a bit dear at over a grand, if you care even less than that about money go for the brand new sony 24 inch 16:10 widescreen that does 1920x1200 heaven

where did all my money go, ahh... [-peep-], forgot that i lived in london
 
Loardkaos and Tempus you are both wrong.

Never trust general statements like brand A is better than brand B. Sometimes even the highest quality monitors occasionally don't perform as promised.

Like fingerprints, All monitors are unique and there are variations in all electronic components. Even companies that use the same CRT can produce widely varying quality of products. In the real world, all things are not equal, when it comes to the electronics, assembly, and quality of alignment at the factory wrapped around the CRT.

For example: designers from different companies can interpret the application and design notes from the CRT manufacture slightly different, thus there is variation in the electronics design. Some manufactures are more interested in volume than quality. These types of manufacturers will take a shorter amount of time aligning the monitors convergence, geometry etc. on the assembly line.

Manufacturers do not modify the CRT, most manufacturers purchase the CRT and deflection yoke as a combination from the CRT manufacturer. Thus the CRT manufacturer does most of the alignment of the two. I have found in this case the specifications published by the CRT manufacturer are typically wider than manufacturers who purchase the yoke and CRT separately and do there own alignment. In general check the manufacturer specifications for convergence, this is usually a good indication of how well the tube and yoke are mated.

At one time most monitors where manufactured in Japan. As the market put price pressure on the manufacturers they move production to places like Taiwan. Now most production has moved to Mainland China, Korea and other countries where the cost of labor is cheaper. As a matter of fact it is difficult these days to even figure out who designed a specific model and who is actually the manufacturer. In my 15 years plus in the monitor industry, I have visited many of the monitor factories in the Far East. You would be surprised to find out who is doing the designing and manufacturing of your favorite products. In all cases I'm under an NDA so I cannot disclose details. Most so-called manufacturers rely on multiple different OEM manufacturers to design and produce their products. Just because it has brand "XYZ" and company "XYZ" is a real manufacture, it does not mean they actually designed and produced the product. OEM manufacturing is very common in the industry, not only monitors but many electronic components. The only way to find this information is to contact the manufacturer and ask.

All of the items I mention above have a direct impact on the price and quality of the final product. Other impacts on price can be directly attributed to the marketing costs of the manufacture and the cost of doing business.

When you purchase an electronic device what you are really purchasing in my opinion is the company that sold you the product. What I mean by that is, will the company stand by its products should you have a problem. How easy will it be to get in touch with their tech support should you need them. Do they offer special services like enhanced warranties that you may require etc. Do your homework before you make a purchase. For example, Find ask the manufacturer what their convergence specs are.

Convergence is one of the key measures of a monitors image quality. Unfortunately most manufacturers do not publish brightness specifications or convergence so I recommend that you call and e-mail the technical support line of the manufacturer and reseller before you buy. First time how long it takes you to reach a human or an e-mail response and then ask them some questions about the monitor you are considering. You don't want to sit on hold; you want to talk to knowledgeable people. They aren't trained to "polish" the answers like sales reps might, but you'll get a sense for how technically competent and knowledgeable they are and how the company will treat you after the purchase.

Good Luck

Jim Witkowski
Chief Hardware Engineer
Cornerstone / Monitorsdirect.com



Jim at http://www.monitorsdirect.com
 
I plan on buying the G400. What is a good price? I found it on pricewatch for $480, is that good? Also, do you think with the new G420 the price of the G400 may come down some?

Someday I will stop asking all the questions!
 
try sony, im not too sure i just saw a review in one of my DV mags, sorry

where did all my money go, ahh... [-peep-], forgot that i lived in london