[citation][nom]Airrax[/nom]This could go either way if Asus succeeds. Having a second 'casual gamer' console would split the market between casual console and hardcore console. [/citation]
You think Sony and Microsoft are just going to roll over and say "OK. Let ASUS have all of our potential profits." You obviously don't understand how Capitalism works.
[citation][nom]Airrax[/nom]Now Microsoft and Sony wouldn't have to focus on dumbing down their hardware or software for a separate mass of people. [/citation]
Motion controllers expand the capabilities of the hardware. They add a new genre of games and a new way to interact with the console in ways other than games. I fail to see how that is "dumbing down their hardware."
[citation][nom]Airrax[/nom]Besides the fact that both Microsoft and Sony try to cater, in a sense, to home media as well as gaming (with Netflix and Blu-Ray), they wouldn't have to worry about creating the next boogy or 'flap your arms around like a genius game (although the latter can be fun when drunk).[/citation]
You really don't get it. Microsoft and Sony WANT to worry about making motion games. They want a share of the Wii market. You know. Capitalism. Profits. Ya.
[citation][nom]Airrax[/nom]The problem, though, is that the rift between hardcore gamer and casual gamer would be blurred in the next few generations when the hardware cost and visual rendering overlap. For the immediate, it would be a benefit to both the hardcore and casual gamer. For the long run it could cause enough direct competition that Asus, Microsoft, Nintendo, and Sony would be more worried about market share than the game/hardware itself (thankfully Sony hasn't fallen into this step yet!). I'm all for 'reinventing' gaming, but Nintendo just takes away from those of us that want a more advanced environment.[/citation]
No. That's just nonsense. Hardcore gamers are on the rise. Casual gamers are on the rise. When there's demand, there will be people there to fill the demand. This alarmist crap that you're spouting is complete nonsense. This ASUS thing, if it ever hits the market, can only be good for gaming all around. It can only be good for consumers to have more choice and give more competition to the providers.
This idea that you have that there is only enough room for hardcore games or casual games needs to stop. It's simply not true. It's just expanding the market, which is a great thing for us gamers.