Can too litle Amps hurt the graphic card?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the Tom's Hardware community: where nearly two million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Are you saying you do not pay if you use more power? I am talking efficiency here not PFC

Think of it this way.

2 PCs

PC 1 and 2 are the same but the psu is different

PC 1

400 watts DC. The PSU is 60 % efficient.

so 400 + 40% = 560 watts from the wall

PC 2

400 watts DC. The psu is 82 % efficient
400 + 18% = 472 watts

Thats 88 watts different EVER hour the PC is on....

A little over 2 kilowatt hours saved if the pc is on all day....

Also 80+ means less heat too....
 
Not to nitpick, but 3.3 x 18 = 60 watts + 5 x 30 = 150 watts, so actually its 210 watts for the 3.3 and the 5 volt. If theyre off that much already, Im betting the psu is as suspect as their numbers. That leaves a total of 290 for the 12 volt rails. If as was stated earlier that a GTS pulls max 10 amps, thats 120 watts right there, leaving 170 for the rest of the 12v system. And remember this, you never ever want to max out your power , ever. Undervolting your hardware will burn it up, as well as the psu of course
 

They are combined rails(most likely center tapped from the same transformer) similar to the way you can get more 12 volts if you use less 3.3 and 5[they are clearly linked too]......they are all linked...this is a normal case on most psu's(i still have some doubt about its rating...but if i can keep my system under 350[with the exception to extreme everything load]i think the OP "should" still be ok...at least for now...a year from now....not sure)

You want to read something fun check out the sticker on the Corsair HX620
50 amps constant out of a 620 watt psu leaving 20 watts for the 3.3, 5 and the negative stuff
 
LOL 20 watts, not thatd be a miracle! I know my 420 watt psu can kick 29 amps to the 12s, and 25 seems weak for a 500 watter, to me. Im using an opty 185, a GTS 320 with everything else normal, or lite. So I know Im skimpin, but I KNOW Im skimpin. Hey, those 20 watts come with static just in case? heheh
 
yes, but most psu are labled in an odd way(more so now....since MAX numbers look more impressive)....they can with ease call it a 35 amp psu. Because it can(on paper at least do it...).

Check out corsairs(Its made by Seasonic as well)
corsairsw5.gif

170 + 600(not going to include standby or -12)
so is it a 770 watt psu? No
As long as nothing exceeds the listed maximums and the total output does not go over 620 watts. your good to go.

What Apevia fails to mention is a max for its 12's they just say max for the 3.3 and 5 combined so i had to subtract it from the total....if corsair had not listed it, the figures would look different.

620(total) - 170(for the 3.3 and 5) = 450 / 12 = 37.5 amps.... Does not sound impressive, but thats all you would get if the 3.3 and 5 volt rails where maxed....

It is always important to keep in mind the fact that most psu's rails are all combined and can give there max wattage in a variety of ways....

Damn, i need to write some guides....but i am too lazy...
 
LOL, Im glad you did that. I know that they share the total, and usually theyre giving max values for any rail, which added exceeds the total wattage, but its good for others to read, and yes you should write one, maybe get it pinned?
 
krillz:
Two questions:
You said your XFX8800GTS (640) has an 8 pin connector for PCI-e power. Are you sure it's not a 6 pin connector?
Second, when you said the PC "crashes", did you mean that it occasionally freezes or that it will randomly reboot? If the latter, it's probably power related - especially if it happens under heavy system load.

An OC'd G80 8800GTS/640 MB needs about 120 watts of power.

For PSU ratings, ignore any rating that says "peak power". It's meaningless. If you are operating that close to the upper edge of PSU capacity, you need a heavier PSU.

I went over to the Apevia website and looked at the pictures and specications. The pictures seem to show pretty light heatsinks. Specs say full rated output at 25 c. Under load, it will heat up. Based on data from PSU manufacturers who do publish such data (most don't), you need to derate a PSU from 1 to 2% per degree C. over PSU rated operating temp. So if internal temp goes up just 10 deg. C., this 500 watt PSU turns into a 400 to 450 watt PSU. This is far different from a 430 watt PSU rated at full output at 50 deg. C. My impression of Apevia is that you would have received a better PSU if they dispensed with the acrylic and LED fans and put that money into the electronics.

croc:
Your automotive analogy really isn't accurate. An inadequate power condition (an overloaded PSU) is supposed to shut that PSU down. A more accurate automotive analogy would be "running on empty". You may still have some gas in the bottom of the tank, but it's not enough to reliably feed the fuel system.


New PC's really load the 12 volt outputs. So new PSU's are designed for that. Older PSU's were designed for older PC's that needed more 5 volt power. So 25 amps out of an older design is not unreasonable. Modern PC's do not need all that 5 volt capacity. But it's included because it might be a replacement PSU for an older computer.

nukemaster:
"They are combined rails(most likely center tapped from the same transformer) similar to the way you can get more 12 volts if you use less 3.3 and 5[they are clearly linked too]......"

That's sort of a simplification. The limitation is actually determined by the primary power circuits (how much power the switching transistors can provide and the size of the main power transformer) and the thermal characteristics (heatsinks, ventilation, and layout). "More power" costs. That combined with good design and conservative ratings is responsible for the difference a $20 no-name PSU from China and a $100 to $150 1st or 2nd tier PSU.

My Antec 650 watt TP3 box says "650 watt continuous output at 50 deg. C." It also say that the max 12 volt out is 624 watts, leaving 26 watts for everything else. <Snicker>

"Quick and dirty" under load PSU voltage checks (carefully, carefully) of the main outputs with DMM black lead grounded and red lead inserted into the back of the various PSU connector pins plugged into the motherboard:
yellow, yellow/black, and yellow/blue wires: +12 v
red: +5 volt
orange: +3.3 volts
All readings should be +- 5%.

While we are talking about PSU's, if you have a suspected bad PSU, also check the grey wire on pin 8. It provides a control signal called "PwrOK" that the CPU needs to start booting. With the PC off, it should be at 0 volts. It should go to around 5 volts (anything over 3.6 volts will be OK) within .5 seconds after pressing the power switch. You can have all the power outputs present. But if you don't have this, your PSU is broke and your PC won't boot.

I also have been thinking about doing a basic PSU guide. I am getting tired of writing the same things over and over in PSU threads. Thats how my "Troubleshooting a Dead System" guide evolved.
 
Last year, when I got an MSI MBOX K9N6SGM-V, and I put in an Antec Truepower 500 to replace the cheap 400 watt PSU. The Newegg photo showed only the model number (SL-400TF), but it turned out to be an Apex.

Well, I put that Apex psu in an old 2.8 Northwood, i865PERL, with an AIW Radeon 9800 Pro box, and within a few months, it died. It took the motherboard with it, so I was out an old PC mainly set up to record video tapes to the hard drive so we could convert them to DVD.

That's what using a cheap psu can do. I should have just tossed it instead, and gotten at least a tier 3 psu for the legacy pc. While it was working, it didn't crash the PC. Just when it died, the motherboard did too, and I'm not sure of the processor or the graphics card because I haven't gotten an AGP board to test them. Instead, I got a TV Wonder card for my MSI Athlon X2 pc.

So, always get at least a tier 3 psu, but better yet, a tier 2. We now have two Antec Neo 550's in our two main PC's with ASUS 690G boards, and the Antec Truepower 500 in the MSI. Since Coolermaster dropped to tier 5, I decided to retire the Coolermaster Realpower 450 that we'd been using in our son's PC. That might have been the last tier 3 psu they ever made. It was the only good one on a list at the forums a couple of years ago when I bought it after reading a review in Maximum PC.
 
That can be a problem when companies change oem suppliers - especially fo rthe worse. They are able to trade on their previous reputation. Or a particular brand may use two oem's across its product range.

The computer at my house in Texas is a simple basic box for internet, email, some scanning - just a basic home computer. Had a 600 MHz PII Celeron before. My sister-in-law put the whole McAfee Security Suite on it. The thing took 7 minutes to boot. Replaced it about 5 or 6 years ago with a PC using a 2.6 GHz P4 Celeron with 512 MB RAM in an integrated Asus motherboard. A 250 watt PSU would have been good enough. I planned to use a 350 watt PSU. No Fry's near Dallas at the time, Compusa didn't have anything that I liked. The smallest name brand PSU that Best Buy had in stock was a 450 watt Antec. It's so lightly loaded that the exhaust air isn't more than 5 deg. F above ambient.

I put the 650 watt Antec in Box #1 simply because I found it on sale. This year, I wanted to pick up a Q6600 G0. Got one at Fry's bundled with an inexpensive ECS motherboard for $280, Antec 550 TP3 half priced at about $45 (SALE!!), and 2 GB of OCZ DDR2-800 rebated to $50. So, for about $100 and upgrade trickle-down, I will have another reasonably well performing system.

The Antec 550 and 650 watt TP3's are advertised as each having three 12 volt rails. I don't think that's true. On both of mine, I read straight short circuits with an ohmmeter between any two 12 volt lines on any two connectors.

And speaking of multiple computers, two questions from J. S. Casteel's Geek Test:
(with apologies to Jeff Foxworthy)
1. If you have more computers in the house than people, you might be a geek.
2. If you have a home network and you live alone, ...
 




When you combind the 2 rails it allows it to draw apms off more than one rail. Why would a video card manufacturer ship their cards with the adaptor????? 1 12v. rail rated at 18 amps is NOT enough power when the card is working under heavy load. Manufacturers make 2, 4, single rail PSU's PC Power & Cooling makes single rail high amperage PSU's so the PCI-e connector on the PSU will work. On multi rail PSU's you have to combined the rails with the VIDEO CARD MANUFATURER SUPPLIED ADAPTOR. The manufacturer does not ship this cable with the video card for sh@*s and giggles. I suggest a single rail high amperage PSU. Read PCPC definition on single and multi rails. A multi rail is 1 rail split apart. Do a little research before telling someone BAD information or what your assumptions are.Sorry cousin (it) didn't mean to leave you out, your head probably hurts from strocking (it) to much.first off

http://www.pcpower.com/technology/myths/
 
The OP brought up a great question... and I haven't seen it definitively answered...

Would having too weak of a PSU for your rig potentially damage the components? I don't think the OP was really asking about the stability issues... we all know PSUs can cause that... but can a PSU that is being asked to do too much actually damage components?
 
My Antec 650 watt TP3 box says "650 watt continuous output at 50 deg. C." It also say that the max 12 volt out is 624 watts, leaving 26 watts for everything else.
Its made by Seasonic, Thats why :)

That's sort of a simplification. The limitation is actually determined by the primary power circuits (how much power the switching transistors can provide and the size of the main power transformer) and the thermal characteristics (heatsinks, ventilation, and layout). "More power" costs. That combined with good design and conservative ratings is responsible for the difference a $20 no-name PSU from China and a $100 to $150 1st or 2nd tier PSU.
Yeah, Simplification works best i find...It keeps confusion to a minimum...

Go write your guide so i can just link to it....
 

Some cheap PSU;s will not turn off if asked to do too much, Instead they will either under or overvolt components. This can and will damage parts(some parts are more sensitive then others....a fan can take almost anything :) a video card given a voltage that is too high may damage its own voltage regulation system killing the video card....)....Thats why good psus have over and under protection for voltage(to protect your system) and current(to protect them selves)...