surphninja :
Math Geek :
it is not exactly that wide open but it is troubling all the same. a court still has to grant a warrant to force the third party to share the info. they can ask for it but the company can deny the request. it's not like they have a guy at a desk in MS HQ from the gov reading and skimming at will. MS/Apple/Google want money for that info so they want to keep it private until someone PAYS to sit there skimming at their leisure. pay the money though and you can surf their database all you want
They don't have to get a warrant. Once you've shared the information with their servers, all they need is a subpoena, which is not difficult to get nor does it require probable cause.
Of course, if Snowden is to be believed, they do have ready access and a guy at a desk just skimming it at will.
Pretty much most federal agencies
already have data sharing agreements, under NDA, with all major software collectors. The FBI doesn't even need to subpoena Google, they just have their guy go through the data directly and pull out what they want. It's full access for them to anything Google, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon, Yahoo or any other entity collects.
That is what makes this extremely unsettling. Cortana shouldn't be storing all these data at MS, it should be stored locally. There is absolutely zero need to send the data to MS, everything can be analyzed locally, it's at least an order of magnitude easier then sending everything to MS to be analyzed and returned. They are doing it centrally as an excuse for massive data collection. And Cortana is just one part of it, most of the really crazy collection isn't even from Cortana. By default, once you link your PC with a MS account, every application you open, every tab on a browser, every site you access, every file you play,
everything you do is sent off to MS for analysis and long term storage. You might as well have a MS employee sitting next to your computer 24/7/365. Their reason for doing this is to get data on how people are using their computers, yet this data can be used for far more nefarious things.