Archived from groups: rec.games.roguelike.misc (More info?)
David Damerell .-- .-. --- - . ---...
> quoting Loonie <loonie2@tlen.pl>:
>>So, regarding this, the "chaingun" seems to be a submachine gun as it uses
>>pistol ammo, so it should have a single shot mode also.
>
> This is a pointless argument from realism. Doom's chaingun fills the
> function of an SMG; fires pistol ammo quickly. But it's depicted as a
> rotary-barrel gun. It's not like any real weapon anyway.
Realism has something to do with gameplay, it gives some indication what
unrealistic things could be and behave. Unrealistic things also follow the
same logic rules as realistic ones. (Look at 95% of the aliens from movies,
they are more less human-like, human-thinking, etc.) This is the interest
of exploring the reality. Why proceed by blind experiment, when all the
knowledge verified by the centuries of human experiences are just around
the corner? No point to create everything from the scratch.
--
Loonie
---------------------------------------
Respondit Pilatus quod scripsi scripsi.
http://www.crawl.webpark.pl
David Damerell .-- .-. --- - . ---...
> quoting Loonie <loonie2@tlen.pl>:
>>So, regarding this, the "chaingun" seems to be a submachine gun as it uses
>>pistol ammo, so it should have a single shot mode also.
>
> This is a pointless argument from realism. Doom's chaingun fills the
> function of an SMG; fires pistol ammo quickly. But it's depicted as a
> rotary-barrel gun. It's not like any real weapon anyway.
Realism has something to do with gameplay, it gives some indication what
unrealistic things could be and behave. Unrealistic things also follow the
same logic rules as realistic ones. (Look at 95% of the aliens from movies,
they are more less human-like, human-thinking, etc.) This is the interest
of exploring the reality. Why proceed by blind experiment, when all the
knowledge verified by the centuries of human experiences are just around
the corner? No point to create everything from the scratch.
--
Loonie
---------------------------------------
Respondit Pilatus quod scripsi scripsi.
http://www.crawl.webpark.pl