Hi guys!
I am moving to a new house in a few months, and, I'm looking to soundboard my ideas on home networking with people who have actual knowledge. I'll briefly go over my planned setup, looking forward to any suggestions:
1. Space: a townhouse laid over four floors of approx 50sqm each, central areas of interest for each level are listed below.
1a. Ground Floor: wife's study, kitchen, dining room, terrace/garden
1b. First Floor: my command centre/gaming room, main living room
1c. Second Floor: kids' bedrooms
1d. Third Floor: master bedroom
I need a customisable mixed wired/wireless network solution for the entire house. The main issue is verticality, with the master bedroom on the top floor the connection can't taper off the higher up the house one goes. It would be nice to get a half-decent link for music streaming for BBQs too.
Another issue, though I'm not sure how significant, is network congestion. We have a workstation and a laptop each, my wife's OSX, and I'm Windows. The other tech in no particular order: three phones, a Google Home Mini/Google Home/Nest Hub/Home Hub for each main area listed above, smart home tech (some of which operates on separate mesh networks): a couple of Philips Hue lights, Smart TV, games console, Chromecast, Chromecast Audio, a couple of DEN light switches, and some kitchen appliances.
2. Solutions:
2a. Gigabit Internet: I'm fortunate enough to be living in an area where I can get a dedicated Gigabit internet connection (proper, symmetrical dedicated fibre) for the house, and why not, since it's not going to be much more expensive than a typical BT Broadband with line rental. Though, I don't believe there's any point in contemplating a 10 Gigabit connection. My wife's running a 2016 iMac Pro; I'm on a PC with a gigabit ethernet card, would I even be able to take advantage of it?
2b. Mesh WiFi: I am into the Google ecosystem; it's something that works for us at home. With that said, I like the concept of Google WiFi for the ease of use aspect of it. I want a robust, enthusiast-grade solution for the house, but with Google WiFi, it feels like I'm getting that, plus the ease of set up and management integrated into the Google ecosystem. For example, I like the idea of setting up routines for curtailing WiFi during meals. Q: Is it just advertising? How does it compare with the more traditional competition?
3. Questions:
3a. How do I wire? I'm thinking of getting the fibre directly to my First Floor gaming room, that would give me a direct gigabit connection to my PC. I could power the main WiFi router from there as well.
3aa. How does a dedicated fibre connection work in terms of bandwidth sharing?
3ab. Can I have another physical wired connection to my wife's study and into her iMac Pro?
3ac. Should I run a dedicated cable to each of my mesh WiFi points?
3b. How do I WiFi? Something like Google WiFi recommends three Wifi points for the area even twice the size of my house, but I fear verticality presents some challenges. My idea is:
First WiFi point goes in my den, which is on the Second Floor directly above my wife's study.
The second goes all the way up to the Fourth Floor master bedroom.
The third goes to the Ground Floor kitchen/dining room.
Second-floor den and my wife's study are at the "front wall" of the house; meanwhile the kitchen/dining-room is facing the "back wall" with the garden. The thinking is that by placing my third access point there, I can get some coverage for the garden. This setup leaves the kids' floor with no dedicated WiFi point; however, there is one point on each adjacent floor. Also, it's a dedicated gigabit fibre, how bad can the connection get?
I think everything above this point seems pretty straightforward. I am interested to see if there are any glaring bottlenecks or simply if there is a better way of doing things?
I am moving to a new house in a few months, and, I'm looking to soundboard my ideas on home networking with people who have actual knowledge. I'll briefly go over my planned setup, looking forward to any suggestions:
1. Space: a townhouse laid over four floors of approx 50sqm each, central areas of interest for each level are listed below.
1a. Ground Floor: wife's study, kitchen, dining room, terrace/garden
1b. First Floor: my command centre/gaming room, main living room
1c. Second Floor: kids' bedrooms
1d. Third Floor: master bedroom
I need a customisable mixed wired/wireless network solution for the entire house. The main issue is verticality, with the master bedroom on the top floor the connection can't taper off the higher up the house one goes. It would be nice to get a half-decent link for music streaming for BBQs too.
Another issue, though I'm not sure how significant, is network congestion. We have a workstation and a laptop each, my wife's OSX, and I'm Windows. The other tech in no particular order: three phones, a Google Home Mini/Google Home/Nest Hub/Home Hub for each main area listed above, smart home tech (some of which operates on separate mesh networks): a couple of Philips Hue lights, Smart TV, games console, Chromecast, Chromecast Audio, a couple of DEN light switches, and some kitchen appliances.
2. Solutions:
2a. Gigabit Internet: I'm fortunate enough to be living in an area where I can get a dedicated Gigabit internet connection (proper, symmetrical dedicated fibre) for the house, and why not, since it's not going to be much more expensive than a typical BT Broadband with line rental. Though, I don't believe there's any point in contemplating a 10 Gigabit connection. My wife's running a 2016 iMac Pro; I'm on a PC with a gigabit ethernet card, would I even be able to take advantage of it?
2b. Mesh WiFi: I am into the Google ecosystem; it's something that works for us at home. With that said, I like the concept of Google WiFi for the ease of use aspect of it. I want a robust, enthusiast-grade solution for the house, but with Google WiFi, it feels like I'm getting that, plus the ease of set up and management integrated into the Google ecosystem. For example, I like the idea of setting up routines for curtailing WiFi during meals. Q: Is it just advertising? How does it compare with the more traditional competition?
3. Questions:
3a. How do I wire? I'm thinking of getting the fibre directly to my First Floor gaming room, that would give me a direct gigabit connection to my PC. I could power the main WiFi router from there as well.
3aa. How does a dedicated fibre connection work in terms of bandwidth sharing?
3ab. Can I have another physical wired connection to my wife's study and into her iMac Pro?
3ac. Should I run a dedicated cable to each of my mesh WiFi points?
3b. How do I WiFi? Something like Google WiFi recommends three Wifi points for the area even twice the size of my house, but I fear verticality presents some challenges. My idea is:
First WiFi point goes in my den, which is on the Second Floor directly above my wife's study.
The second goes all the way up to the Fourth Floor master bedroom.
The third goes to the Ground Floor kitchen/dining room.
Second-floor den and my wife's study are at the "front wall" of the house; meanwhile the kitchen/dining-room is facing the "back wall" with the garden. The thinking is that by placing my third access point there, I can get some coverage for the garden. This setup leaves the kids' floor with no dedicated WiFi point; however, there is one point on each adjacent floor. Also, it's a dedicated gigabit fibre, how bad can the connection get?
I think everything above this point seems pretty straightforward. I am interested to see if there are any glaring bottlenecks or simply if there is a better way of doing things?
- Will a 5Ghz network work fine considering my space?
- What problems do you see me running into with my setup?
- Is interference going to be an issue? (In other threads, people suggested moving smart tech into a separate mesh network?)
- Is there any point in putting a network switch and playing with a local backup server in the house? I don't do any data-critical work that my Dropbox/Google Drive and One Drive wouldn't be able to handle. My wife, on the other hand, is an author and a designer. Her current setup is adequate for text, between local storage on the iMac and Time Machine, and One Drive, but I feel it does not offer enough redundancy for her work with larger files. I never had an internet connection this fast, so, in practical terms, the question is: what's a more cost-effective solution? Cloud-based storage or a home backup server? How OTT does it sound?
Last edited: