Question i5 8600k vs i5 9400f vs ryzen 5 2600 vs ryzen 7 2700 vs i7 8700k for premier pro

[Shahab99110]

hi, i m going to build a pc for video editing in adobe premiere pro and doing little bit of after effect, gaming is not my priority and i will be not doing that(except for some time) i have narrow down some parts for my build but stuck with processor as a result motherboard and gpu is also not fixed(because i have a fix budget and according to that i have to manage thees parts) my build other than these three part is

ram=====corsair 2400mhz 16x2==32gb

storage==== a)segeate 1tb

b) crusial bxm500 240gb

psu==========vs550

in starting i m going with ryzen 5 2600 and 10606gb but after that i came to know that there is very much less requirement of gpu other than exporting(which in my case is not that much imp because i m wedding videographer and hence delay of 1 hr is ok for me but not much ) and also premier pro is optimised for intel cpu's. after that i again do some research and found these one

with each cpu price i hooked up a gpu which does not break my budget

i5 9400f is the cheapest processor and i7 8700k is the most expensive.

here are the configration that i can do according to my budget

i5 9400f + 1660 oc 6gb

ryzen 5 2600 + 1060 gb

i5 8600k + 1050 ti+ good cooler/ 1650 +normal cooler

ryzen 2 2700 + 1050 ti

i7 8700k + no gpu(no cash left).

"i m getting motherboard of all these at the same price"

also i m getting ryzen 7 1700 on price of ryzen 5 2600 and

ryzen 5 1600 on price of i5 9400f

please consider this also and help me out

which is the best configuration for premier pro and also for future proof

 

[Darkbreeze]

If you're going to use the VS power supply you might just as well not buy a processor because you'll save money on hardware that way. LOL.

Seriously, that's just about the worst power supply Corsair has ever offered, and it's a pile of garbage. I realize you have a budget, but sometimes that doesn't matter and you simply have to stop, wait, and save until you have enough budget to afford the parts that make sense. Buying only what you can squeeze in, usually doesn't make sense, especially when it comes to the power supply which not surprising is the part that usually gets skimped on and it shouldn't, since it is the MOST important part. There is NO other part more important than the power supply because there is no other part that can affect ALL other parts, in the way that the power supply can.

Power supply doesn't work RIGHT, then NOTHING works RIGHT.

If you can even CONSIDER buying an 8700k, then you can certainly shift funds in the build and go with something like the Ryzen 5 2600, a decent (Or at least FAR more decent than that VS series unit) Seasonic S12II-520 or 620 or Antec VP-550, or even a Corsair CX550m, which are all miles better than that VS unit. If you buy that, you are wasting your money. Throwing it in the trash.

Since you're not gaming, ANY of those CPUs will likely do the job more than adequately. Also, unless you are absolutely certain that you will be working with projects large enough to justify the 32GB of RAM, you'd be wise to settle for 16GB for now, and put that extra money towards a better PSU and maybe some of it towards the CPU and graphics card. You can always add another 16GB later down the road if you need to, easily. You can't easily change to a better CPU or graphics card later.

 

[Shahab99110]

If you're going to use the VS power supply you might just as well not buy a processor because you'll save money on hardware that way. LOL.

Seriously, that's just about the worst power supply Corsair has ever offered, and it's a pile of garbage. I realize you have a budget, but sometimes that doesn't matter and you simply have to stop, wait, and save until you have enough budget to afford the parts that make sense. Buying only what you can squeeze in, usually doesn't make sense, especially when it comes to the power supply which not surprising is the part that usually gets skimped on and it shouldn't, since it is the MOST important part. There is NO other part more important than the power supply because there is no other part that can affect ALL other parts, in the way that the power supply can.

Power supply doesn't work RIGHT, then NOTHING works RIGHT.

If you can even CONSIDER buying an 8700k, then you can certainly shift funds in the build and go with something like the Ryzen 5 2600, a decent (Or at least FAR more decent than that VS series unit) Seasonic S12II-520 or 620 or Antec VP-550, or even a Corsair CX550m, which are all miles better than that VS unit. If you buy that, you are wasting your money. Throwing it in the trash.

Since you're not gaming, ANY of those CPUs will likely do the job more than adequately. Also, unless you are absolutely certain that you will be working with projects large enough to justify the 32GB of RAM, you'd be wise to settle for 16GB for now, and put that extra money towards a better PSU and maybe some of it towards the CPU and graphics card. You can always add another 16GB later down the road if you need to, easily. You can't easily change to a better CPU or graphics card later.

If you're going to use the VS power supply you might just as well not buy a processor because you'll save money on hardware that way. LOL.

Seriously, that's just about the worst power supply Corsair has ever offered, and it's a pile of garbage. I realize you have a budget, but sometimes that doesn't matter and you simply have to stop, wait, and save until you have enough budget to afford the parts that make sense. Buying only what you can squeeze in, usually doesn't make sense, especially when it comes to the power supply which not surprising is the part that usually gets skimped on and it shouldn't, since it is the MOST important part. There is NO other part more important than the power supply because there is no other part that can affect ALL other parts, in the way that the power supply can.

Power supply doesn't work RIGHT, then NOTHING works RIGHT.

If you can even CONSIDER buying an 8700k, then you can certainly shift funds in the build and go with something like the Ryzen 5 2600, a decent (Or at least FAR more decent than that VS series unit) Seasonic S12II-520 or 620 or Antec VP-550, or even a Corsair CX550m, which are all miles better than that VS unit. If you buy that, you are wasting your money. Throwing it in the trash.

Since you're not gaming, ANY of those CPUs will likely do the job more than adequately. Also, unless you are absolutely certain that you will be working with projects large enough to justify the 32GB of RAM, you'd be wise to settle for 16GB for now, and put that extra money towards a better PSU and maybe some of it towards the CPU and graphics card. You can always add another 16GB later down the road if you need to, easily. You can't easily change to a better CPU or graphics card later.

i can get antech vp-550 and thanks for the opinion

 

[Darkbreeze]

Yes, it would be a better alternative.