The Orig Ralph :
i believe i understand what you're saying, but i'll clarify - a) i couldn't understand why the AI Suite would conflict with other reporting or monitoring utilities, but wanted to see if that was the case - i dis-abled AI Suite by exiting it in the taskbar, then "ending the process" in task manager, idle temps dropped 3-4C, whether monitoring in XTU or RealTemp, and that drop remained after i un-installed it altogether.
When i read the manual on the AI Suite, and it's been a few months now, irrc the temp reported is what amounts to the cpu's case temp - when i would compare AI performane utility's temp with the other temps in XTU & RealTemp, they were within 5-6 degrees of each other, and as they're reporting core temps, that is the difference that intel indicates to expect. But the Asus reported temp would hit a ceiling of 67C (somewhere in the high 50s it's temp would start to equal the temps XTU and RealTemp were reporting for core temps) - Why would Asus ignore, in it's temp reporting, core temps hitting 99-100C?
The suggestion to un-install it was from the intel reps in that overheating thread re the i7-4790k & i5-4690k CPUs, and it was a generic suggestion solution, not directed at me specific - i only tried it in desperation and did see some positive result.
Then when i cleared the CMOS (per intel's suggestion) and temps dropped considerably more, approx 6-7C, i wanted to see if that cleared the issue between AI Suite as i couldn't understand a mobo mfgr's utility mis-reporting like it was and causing a rise in temps. The same situation returned, where MAX temp AI Suite would show was 67C - and oddly it remains there after a stress test, even though temps have dropped.
The aspect of the asus monitoring utility that really alarms me though is that it would ignore those high core temps but the situation i'm seeing may be unique to my mobo, i don't know, i do know what i'm seeing though
the other day i re-installed it for a 2nd time with same results. As far as fan control, i'm happy with the settings in the UEFI BIOS - i've adjusted them manually to where i want them. Between the un-installing Ai Suite, clearing CMOS, new cooler and additional case fans, i've got my temps at idle in the low 30s, and editing video files in the low to mid 60s, and XTU stress test in the low to mid 70s with occasional spikes to 79C
There was another anomaly with the Asus suite showing in the taskbar but not running. Someone in the intel thread had noticed this but with asus in the taskbar, adjusting watt limits for turbo boost power max or turbo boost short power max in XTU, you had to use a number that was 1/8th of what you wanted, somehow a multiplier of 8X had been factored into the bios - ie, if you wanted turbo boost power max of 88W, you had to select 11W, and you'd find it at 88 in the BIOS.
i'm fairly certain there was a conflict between my bios (and it's the latest vs) and the asus suite
Yes, there is an issue with AI Suite where it can be discombobulated and has to be uninstalled and reinstalled. There is a utility on RoG Forums designed explicitly to do that. I find that numerous utilities and programs leave what I call ghost images in Task Manager. Among them I can recall Firefox, HWiNFO64, Powerdesk, etc. I surmise this happens when you have a program or utility that has various modules running and when you close them, one of the modules isn't finished doing something it wants to so and remains running. If you restart, it won't restart and you can wind up with 3 or 4 instances in TM.
The thing to recognize is that AI Suite is an suite of utilities, and you're speaking of just one of them.
AI Charger
USB Boost
EZ Update
Network Control
BIOS Flashback
System Info
USB Charger
WiFi Go
WiFi Engine
4-Way Optimization (Auto OC)
- TPU is the BIOS adjustment function thru windows
- EPU is energy Control
- FanXpert auto calibrates all your fans and allows you to set up speed control curves for each channel.
If nothing else, I would set up FanXpert and Flashback. It's not that Ai Suite is ignoring Core Temps, it's just that as a MoBo utility, it exercises no control over core temps.. This is built into the CPU. It has been reported that this behavior has been observed sometimes when running multiple monitoring programs at the same time. You can also shutdown the hw monitor service but leave the fan controller service running to maintain fan control.
If you had problems with AI Suite, uninstall using the utility on the Asus Forums .... and reinstalling is the recommended procedure.
https://rog.asus.com/forum/showthread.php?36977-How-to-Install-Ai-Suite-3!-%28For-People-Who-Cannot-install-the-new-AI-Suite-3%29&highlight=uninstall+cleaner
http://rog.asus.com/forum/showthread.php?34503-AI-Suite-III-Cleaner
You can set the fan curves up in AI suite, then disable Ai suite III from starting up at login, the Asus fan service, that runs as a Windows 7 service, will apply the settings set in AI Suite at boot and not the BIOS settings As long as you don't stop the fan controller service.
I have never used AI Suite to do any BIOS settings adjustments simply because the very act of changing these settings under load can crash the system. It's good for establishing a starting point but all final fine tuning should be done directly in the BIOS.
Again, Intel XTU is "watered down" a bit so as not to put too much of a consistent a load on the CPU. While it's good for a long term stability check since it's cycling prevents and serious temps, you will be able to generate much higher temps doing say video encoding. In addition, with all of the extension sets used in modern CPUs, it doesn't test all of them, leaving you as yet uncertain as to whether your system is still stable when such conditions occur. And the fact that you sometimes get crashes after 4+ hour run is frustrating.
What I do is, say you have established a stable foundation at 4.3 GHz and you're now ready to try 4.4 .... run RoG Bench multitasking test .... upping ya voltages and making adjustments to the "usual suspects" along the way..... if you pass that 2 minute test, you are very close. Run the full benchmark test and if ya pass that, run a 2 hour stress test.
I you can pass an 8 hour Intel XTU tests you are probably very close but not quite sure of a stable OC under all real usage conditions. But after passing that I find that you will often fail under RoG Bench because not only does it not have cyclic loading which puts full stress on the CPU only for short durations, it also is a 'same thing over and over and over again type of loading. RB throws thing at the CPU in varying order so as to present a true muti-tasking environment. I didn't have to make big changes as a result of the RB testing but I did wind up having to make minor changes to either VCCIN, Core or Cache voltages to get past the stress test.