Maxis Insider Says Taking SimCity Offline Not Too Difficult

Status
Not open for further replies.

rantoc

Distinguished
Dec 17, 2009
1,859
1
19,780
Ofc not, all it does currently is to handle the save files for singleplayer... ty EA for your pooooooor choice in drm, hope it bite the company in the ass - HARD!
 

d_kuhn

Distinguished
Mar 26, 2002
704
0
18,990
Their servers can't handle game saving and 'social' crap... how exactly are they going to perform realtime game computation. Sounds like another of those "we can't raise the borderlands 2 level cap without breaking the game" throwaway statements.
 

janetonly42

Honorable
Mar 4, 2013
111
0
10,680
On another site I read EA said they had to keep constant online connection running for single players so their servers could do complex calculations. This lying hack at EA has a job waiting for him in the Obama regime. Last time I checked Sim City is played on a computer and that is what computers are really good at.
 

pxl9190

Distinguished
Jan 27, 2011
21
0
18,510
anyone with a BS degree in computer science, any sort of engineering, or even a high school kid who know how to program, could tell this "always on connnection needed for single player" is total BS.

These people amounts to at least 1/3 of the simcity's target audience. For EA to claim otherwise is an insult to the technical intelligence of the gaming community.
 

wildkitten

Distinguished
May 29, 2008
816
0
18,980
[citation][nom]Chairman Ray[/nom]If their servers are only saving games and doing minor message routing, how in the heck did they get overflooded on the first day?[/citation]
Because it's not what the server are doing but rather the sheer number of people accessing it. Regardless of what the server has to do for the game, it's still switching from user to user.

Now one thing about it, this employee took a major risk. Odds are he/she would get fired for saying something so contradictory that their bosses are saying UNLESS this was meant to float the idea that a single player offline patch may be in the works. I'm not holding my breath, but I could easily see the Maxis people, especially Will Wright, applying pressure of such a thing.
 

bigdragon

Distinguished
Oct 19, 2011
1,107
547
20,160
What I find really interesting is that a single city could easily span an entire region now that we've seen what debug mode is capable of doing. THAT"S the game I want to play! Huge maps, huge cities, full access to highway and rail networks, and so on. That's the game they should have made. It looks like SimCity 5 could have easily been a 3D version of SimCity 3000 Unlimited in which they could have simply sold expansion content on top of. Instead they took the DRM to the extreme. Tons of people today are reporting that they are getting errors about not owning content found in regions. What a mess. EA demonstrates again how to screw things up.
 

ibjeepr

Distinguished
Oct 11, 2012
632
0
19,010
I could have told you that. Whlie playing, it is constantly telling me that the connection to the server has been lost, but it never stops me from playing. Obviously the calculations are being done by my PC, not the server.
 

icepick314

Distinguished
Jul 24, 2002
705
0
18,990
there is an article and video that a modder changed timeout on the game from 20 minutes to even longer so he was able to play it offline indefinitely...

http://www.geek.com/articles/games/modder-proves-simcity-can-run-offline-indefinitely-20130314/

yeah EA and Maxis added online for DRM ONLY and no significant calculations are done on the server like they said...
 

hate machine

Honorable
Jun 14, 2012
255
0
10,780
[citation][nom]mauller07[/nom]Toms is behind, the entire simulation runs offline and a modder has activated debug mode to show that what ea is sprouting is just FUD.http://uk.gamespot.com/news/modder [...] ne-6405296[/citation]

EA is spouting Fear Uncertainty and Doom?
 

hate machine

Honorable
Jun 14, 2012
255
0
10,780
[citation][nom]Chairman Ray[/nom]If their servers are only saving games and doing minor message routing, how in the heck did they get overflooded on the first day?[/citation]

They are cheap and spent the least amount of money possible to get their farm going. Even then they waited quite a while to upscale due to demand which just shows you they aren't willing to put anymore money in besides the cost of bandwidth. I would even be willing to wager they didn't scale up server operations much but instead relied on less people hammering it and disgruntled people giving up and claimed that the lower usage was "increased capacity".
 

shafe88

Distinguished
Jul 6, 2010
854
1
19,015
[citation][nom]ibjeepr[/nom]I could have told you that. Whlie playing, it is constantly telling me that the connection to the server has been lost, but it never stops me from playing. Obviously the calculations are being done by my PC, not the server.[/citation]See right their is some proof you can play without being connected to the server/internet. The only problem is they can't, the problem is they don't want to.
 

shafe88

Distinguished
Jul 6, 2010
854
1
19,015
[citation][nom]uuicked[/nom]Simply put, it is to control video game piracy. Anyone who doesn't see that is blind[/citation]It's not that people don't see it, people just see it as a stupid way of controlling piracy.
 

ddpruitt

Honorable
Jun 4, 2012
1,109
0
11,360
[citation][nom]Chairman Ray[/nom]If their servers are only saving games and doing minor message routing, how in the heck did they get overflooded on the first day?[/citation]

Too few servers, no load balancing, and poorly configured systems. They went the cheap route. For whatever reason EA doesn't know how to properly configure servers or set up a proper dynamic load balancing system across all of it's services.
 

sot010174

Distinguished
Mar 12, 2004
89
0
18,630
What pisses me the most as a paying customer: I have to put up with this and everyone torrenting the pirated version most probably won't encounter any nags.
 

amoralman

Honorable
May 20, 2012
93
0
10,630
So... always-online prevents cheating? WTF do I care if Joe cheats in his single player game?!?! Man I can't wait for this trend to be over. As soon as people realize that once the company goes bankrupt, is sold, or the servers are not profitable anymore, they will just shut them down and you will not be able to play your game. Ever. How does this make sense in single player? Really... It beats me how people can buy these games anyways.
 

tomfreak

Distinguished
May 18, 2011
1,334
0
19,280
People need to stop buying these kind DRM and complain at the login queue. Didnt Diablo 3 thought u anything? why still wanna jump in and pre-order & expect it to run flawlessly? Are these guy retard?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.