Quick Takes: 13 Mid-Tower Cases Rounded-Up

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the Tom's Hardware community: where nearly two million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Status
Not open for further replies.

anartik

Distinguished
Jul 14, 2008
56
0
18,630
As far as the Stacker, Cosmos, and Silverstone TJ's I can understand leaving them off since they have been beat to death with reviews and monthly system builds by just about every hardware site. And of course since case prices vary $80-400 in this article its more like a random sampling(with 100’s possible no one is ever going to be happy).

Personally I would not buy much of anything not made by Lian Li or Silverstone (of course with some exceptions like the NZXT Khaos and maybe Stacker EVO). If it has plastic, paint, too much steel, flimsy aluminum, poorly designed ventilation & vibration control or gaudiness I would not touch it with your motherboard. I tend to see a quality case as more of an investment and I often reuse cases for multiple system rebuilds. Sometimes you have to cut corners to stay on budget but putting a good computer in a cheap/dysfunctional case is like putting a luxury interior in a Yugo... Some of these cases are OK but there is not one that I would buy. Even for Lian Li and Silverstone they are some of the less popular and more obscure models. The Zalman at $399 is a joke with the best feature being that you can see and read "Zalman" from every possible viewing angle lol. You can get a far better “high end” case $100-200 less.

As for the comment about the PC-B25 and the complicated HD mounting... get real. It has the same system as my Lian Li PC-V1010. Screw in 4 screws to the drive with 4 rubber grommets and slide the drive into the rack. It's simple, secure and vibration free. I guess you would rather have regular mounting screws or the cheap, easily broken, plastic mounting system of the Chinese cases that even have a mounting system? The Lian Li solution (also in LanCool) just works and you won't need any sort of anti vibration kit for your drives. I don't really care for the PC-B25 design but I would assume it is as vibration and noise free as mine. My Lian Li does have ESATA connections but who cares. If anything the panel has too many connections resulting in a massive bundle of cables sitting in the top of the case. I don’t know about you but I prefer to have my wiring mess behind the computer with the convenience of maybe a couple USB & a firewire in front.
 

0bsidian

Distinguished
Nov 12, 2008
1
0
18,510
I ordered an Antec 300 case before this article was published, it hasn't arrived yet, but I see a potential flaw. The PSU in the image is clearly mounted right-side-up, as if you'd mount it at the top of any number of ATX cases. What about the people that have those extra large 120mm fans on the bottom of the PSU? Are they forced to mount this unit only that direction or can you flip it around in the Antec 300 so the fan is at least getting some air flow? Or is there a gap not shown where the PSU will get 'enough' air even though it's mounted in the bottom? Thanks for any answers in advance.

I like the article but it seems to be missing some very small technical details that would help builders make the decisions needed to buy one case over the other.
 

mbaroud

Distinguished
May 2, 2008
9
0
18,510
I wish there was something similair for SFF cases. Best of the BEST!!!
I am looking for a SFF case to put in dual 4870 X2 with my DFI M2RS790GX
 

anartik

Distinguished
Jul 14, 2008
56
0
18,630
Obsidian... I would not worry about the PS. Aside from the fact you can probably mount your PS either way look at image 9/12 and the elevated PS support rails inside the case. Its hard to tell from the picture but you probably have .75-1" clearance which is plenty for the 120mm fan (probably low speed controlled anyway) in your PS. I have a bottom 1000w PS w/ bottom 140mm fan and it is just fine with about 1" of clearance.
 

kep55

Distinguished
Dec 31, 2007
899
37
19,040
The one thing I really like about my CoolerMaster Praetorian is the removable mobo tray. IT makes working on the mobo easier and simpler. Too bad none of these cases are as user friendly or advanced.
 
G

Guest

Guest
The reason you had trouble installing the hard drives in the LanCool PC-K1 is because you put them in backwards! I recently bought one of these cases and it caught me out the first time as well. If you look at the photos on the instruction sheet you'll see the hard drives are supposed to be inserted from the other side of the chassis and the cables routed behind the motherboard and out through the holes in the motherboard tray (which is removable and has metal cable clips on the back to keep things tidy).
 
G

Guest

Guest
It looks like you put the hard drives in backwards in the Lian LI PC-B25 as well (same design as the LanCool PC-K1). You're supposed to remove the right hand side panel and install the drives from the opposite side to what you'd normally expect.
 
G

Guest

Guest
I must say I'm slightly disappointed in the amount of detail about each case - this doesn't help a lot. And yes, keeping the info about each case on one page would make it more readable.

Still interesting read...
 
G

Guest

Guest
It would be really cool to see cases tested (with and without RAID) for acoustic noise levels and vibrations.
 
G

Guest

Guest
FYI, the Zalman does come with a fan controller, ZM-MC1 Multi-connector that can be separated to 3-pin connectors of 5V and 12V when connected to a 4 pin power connector.
 

StfnoPad

Distinguished
Feb 20, 2009
4
0
18,510
[citation][nom]zpyrd[/nom]Attention Article Author: Siggy MoerschYour mid-tower round up article is good. However laying out your article over 41 pages is too excessive. By the time I reached the 20th page I became bored of flipping through pages with only a few paragraphs on each page. I'm certain your article could have fit on fewer pages. I believe one page for each case reviewed would provide a clean article layout.[/citation]

I agree, but until the author fixes this what you can do is press the print link at the end of the article. Then everything is joined in just one page. Works wonders!!
 

nkarasch

Distinguished
Nov 13, 2007
287
0
18,780
Would a GTX295 run into the hard drives in the 300? I don't have that card, its just the biggest I can think of.

In my Antec 900 my 8800GTS G92's 6 pin power plug and sata power plugs are touching. That case is a lot bigger to.

I still really want a 300 though
 
Status
Not open for further replies.