Stay out of the registry.
Are you switching the headset's connectivity between wireless, and wired (USB or 3.5mm). Different drivers are needed and the headsets may well end up with some different designation number/name so you/Windows knows which "device driver" to select depending on connectivity.
Do you have the applicable headset drivers? Try a reinstall first.
In Device Manager ensure that the "Show hidden devices" is checked via the View tab.
Next, in Device Manager > Audio inputs and outputs find the " 2-CORSAIR VIRTOUSO Wireless Gaming Headset".
Right-click the undesired headset(s) and click Uninstall device.
FYI:
https://www.technipages.com/windows-10-how-to-update-and-uninstall-drivers...